HOME | DD

asdfmovienerd39 In reply to FutureTrunks22 [2014-09-01 19:16:37 +0000 UTC]

Thanks! Who do you think will win?

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

FutureTrunks22 In reply to asdfmovienerd39 [2014-09-02 07:17:02 +0000 UTC]

I like Dipper and Mabel

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

asdfmovienerd39 In reply to mon-ra [2014-08-31 15:32:26 +0000 UTC]

You're forgetting Shaggy and Scooby are master of disguises and Dipper and Mabel (especially Mabel) are probably gullible enough to believe them, being little kids and all. Scooby and Shaggy also have  the speed advantage as they seem to be able to run across an entire mansion in 5 minutes. And since this Death Battle, the "no killing" thing would be removed. 

Also,  you're forgetting Sccooby and Shaggy have stronger Toon Force, and as seen in their newest movie they  are capable of biting through solid steel with ease. 

And I remember them saving the rest of the gang in one episode. Also, Scooby Snacks can  play a big part in this as Zacmariozero said in his Scooby and Shaggy vs The Animatronics fight: " Then we have the Scooby Snacks. These treats are usually used to make them do stuff for the rest of the gang. But, in a way, they boost their confidence in completing the task at hand."


...Aaaaand they teamed up with Batman and Robin to  beat Joker and Penguin (some of the most dangerous Batman villains ever). Plus, unless you go by Toon Force as strong as these guys,  two trash can lids banging against your head would at the very least cause some major brain damage. And since Dipper and Mabel don't have as strong of Toon Force....yeah, Dipper and Mabel wouldn't last if Scoobs and Shaggy try that attack, also Scooby is a black-belt in karate.

👍: 0 ⏩: 2

mon-ra In reply to asdfmovienerd39 [2014-09-01 01:02:00 +0000 UTC]

No I haven't forgotten about Shaggy's and Scooby's ability play dress up, and sure Mabel might fall for then, but Dipper would give them the 'oh really' sarcastic look.  And yes I am aware that the no killing rule has been removed, but what I was referring to is that Scooby and Shaggy don't have the killing instinct.  Unlike Dipper and Mabel who have shown that they can and will kill.

As for this toon force, Dipper has fought a multi-bear and jumped over 30 ft. and punched his way into a giant robot.  So he's pretty tough for a 12 year old.  Mabel herself, while she prefers to be the adorable air head, has proven that she's more crafty and ruthless than people give her credit for.

I wouldn't consider Scooby snacks to be any type of power booster like spinach.  After all for the most part the Gang just uses them to bribe Scooby and Shaggy to do stupid stuff like being live bait.  Also it's a popular fan theory that they are actually narcotic which is why they are always jittery and nervous all the time except when eating them.

Yes the Joker and Penguin are two of Batman's most dangerous foes.  But that's in the comic.  In the cartoon, they're as dangerous as an elementary school bully who only knows how to do wedgies.  While the Mystery Twins never had any formal training they are quick and agile with creative minds.  They would have next to no chance in an official karate fight, in a street brawl where anything goes, a black belt means almost next to nothing.  Trust me I saw a brown belt student get taken down by a mugger because the thief got a lucky hit and punched the guy in the face.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

asdfmovienerd39 In reply to mon-ra [2014-09-01 01:50:21 +0000 UTC]

Also. Shaggy and Scooby trained with wrestlers, and Mable doesn't really have any combat experience. I'm just gonna copy and paste another comment I saw: 

"Their best bet/advantage are their cartoon physics since that would allow them to take punishment as well as dish it out which would essentially allow them to over power Dipper and Mabel.

But I'm not counting out Dipper and Mabel yet considering Dipper has accomplished feats such as when he fought and even defeated the Multi-Bear, and he seems to be able to endure a lot of punishment/abuse as seen in "Fight Fighters" in which he manages to survive a beating from Rumble McSkirmish (who's punches are shown to be strong enough to break through/destroy cars in seconds) and even managing to still be able to get up and walk afterwards.

Problem is, this is a 2 on 2 battle, and aside from her Grappling Hook, Mabel hasn't really shown much fighting ability or endurance... this means she'd be the first of the two to go down, leaving Dipper to fend for himself against 2 opponents which he wouldn't last long against. "


...Yeah, Mabel doesn't really have any weapons.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

mon-ra In reply to asdfmovienerd39 [2014-09-01 08:29:38 +0000 UTC]

I wouldn't call a couple of hours at Wrestling camp trained, even the WWE stars were cynical about their abilities.  Mabel has shown that she does have fighting skill like in Headhunters where she started facing off against an army of wax sculptors, and did you miss the part when she started beating up zombies!  True she doesn't get into as many fights as Dipper, and often she just supports him from the sideline; but in the few fights that she has had, she does a pretty good job holding her own.  She also has a tolerance for pain, in the first episode she laughs at having splitters.  This proves that she enjoys getting hurt.

Mabel may not have a primary weapon but she turns anything she can get her hands on into a weapon: leaf blower, plug-in candles, karaoke machine.  This girl is Harley Quinn level insane, and that's what makes her scary.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

asdfmovienerd39 In reply to mon-ra [2014-09-01 16:45:24 +0000 UTC]

Shaggy and Scooby can also turn every day objects into weapons.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

mon-ra In reply to asdfmovienerd39 [2014-09-01 19:56:06 +0000 UTC]

Sure they can, but do they ever?  In most of the episodes I've seen they never picked up a blunt instrument to fight off the monsters, or even try to defend themselves.  Preferring to just run away.  Only stepping up when their friends are in danger.  This is why I say they don't have the killer instinct.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

MooMinded In reply to asdfmovienerd39 [2014-08-31 22:41:32 +0000 UTC]

Problem with using the Batman and Robin example is that Bat-Mite was the one who gave them the courage to fight back using his reality manipulation powers, so that technically counts as outside help... plus they were fighting along side Batman and Robin, also outside help. So... yeah, not sure if that can really count as an example of their accomplishments considering those two factors.

Their best bet/advantage are their cartoon physics (or toon force as you call it) since that would allow them to take punishment as well as dish it out which would essentially allow them to over power Dipper and Mabel.

But I'm not counting out Dipper and Mabel yet considering Dipper has accomplished feats such as when he fought and even defeated the Multi-Bear, and he seems to be able to endure a lot of punishment/abuse as seen in "Fight Fighters" in which he manages to survive a beating from Rumble McSkirmish (who's punches are shown to be strong enough to break through/destroy cars in seconds) and even managing to still be able to get up and walk afterwards.

Problem is, this is a 2 on 2 battle, and aside from her Grappling Hook, Mabel hasn't really shown much fighting ability or endurance... this means she'd be the first of the two to go down, leaving Dipper to fend for himself against 2 opponents which he wouldn't last long against. 

... I just realized I'm arguing about the end result of a fight to the finish between Dipper and Mabel vs Scooby and Shaggy... is this the result of sleep deprivation? 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

asdfmovienerd39 In reply to MooMinded [2014-08-31 22:50:14 +0000 UTC]

I agree with  you on everything, and no. Its not sleep deprivation. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

asdfmovienerd39 In reply to edormond19 [2014-08-31 03:55:37 +0000 UTC]

Cool! Although you added "of course" at the  end there and it kind of sounded like you were saying that as fact rather than opinion. I get the feeling  you're underestimating Scooby and Shaggy a fair bit.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0