Comments: 4
ColonelMarksman [2014-05-14 13:02:09 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
This is overall, a fantastic model. This is my favorite style of making a model pop, by using extremely tiny variations in painting the small areas to give overall texture and depth. The front of the model is nearly flawless; the gold chain and the skin on the face is beyond incredible. Actually anywhere you put gold is incredible! The only thing I'll say about the front is with such a good and detailed model, it looks like he's squinting or blind. I think you're skilled enough to give a little sliver of something to emulate eyes (though you and I know that painting full-sized eyes that can be seen from a distance looks stupid). Also you went a tad too dark and spread on the crease of the book's pages, but the text you add will probably nullify that in overall feel.
The back of the model is really great but it looks like you squandered a tiny bit here and there. The purple cloths are really hard to see on that blue armor; I suggest brightening it up for a better pop. The bottom of his right boot looks like it has a bit of drip on the side, probably hard to see. His backpack all around looks a little dull compared to the rest of the model, which unfortunately because its such a large part of him and so red, it shows. It shouldn't take much to add to it, like rivets and on the indentions here and there; you painted the cross-section on the purity seal on his left shoulder around all of that gold, which is fantastic. I wish I could see more of that in the back.
Something I'm a little more neutral about is the ground section he's standing on. It seems a little subtle but with this painting style it is really hard to do. If I stare at it too long it looks like a flake of something I can bite into. I think if you inked some black in the tiny crevices might look better. I also prefer models with battle damage and some dirt but that's just personal preference and not anything I normally emphasize.
Overall, if this were on CMON, I'd give this an 8.5 out of 10. You certainly put a lot of time and effort into this one. May he pulverize the enemies of the Imperium with his psychic blessings!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ColonelMarksman In reply to Budsky [2014-05-17 15:39:46 +0000 UTC]
The concentration squint (dunno the name of such a face) is a really good idea, the problem is the way the mold is on the rest of the facial features doesn't emote that well enough. The only thing you would need to do is somehow make it look like he's gritting his teeth with a bit of a frown.
Studying people's faces when they're squinting in concentration, I think you need to darken the slit a bit more but that's a wide-shot guess. It's really hard in any artistic medium to differentiate from an old wizened face to someone squinting; to avoid the former, lighten the shading. That might work together: lighten the shading and darken the thin line where the eyes are squeezed shut.
Your highlighting skills are so damn awesome that you made wrinkles in his face ... too visible I think!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0