Comments: 17
Midorinokurokami [2014-05-08 02:06:45 +0000 UTC]
Personally I think the main reason why the author refrained from giving Cersei a sword is because if she did she'd be so overpowered and take control of the throne so fast that there'd only be one book
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
FionaCreates In reply to Midorinokurokami [2014-05-08 02:41:01 +0000 UTC]
Oh there's lots of logical reason why Cersie doesn't have a sword. One of which is that to give Cersie a sword and make her a knight, would make a lot of waves. It would say "It's ok for women to fight" ergo Arya isn't such an anomaly and more girls would want to become knights too. Like Sansa. She idolises Cersie. Could you imagine that AU?! XD
It also would make Brienne less effective as a character. Part of what makes Brienne herself is that she has taken it upon herself to just do what she's built for. She's a tank and that's what she does. But you also see her vunerability because you can see that secretly she envies the ladies like Cersie for having their elegance and prettyness, when Cersie also envies Brienne for just doing what she wanted. It makes the story more interesting.
But yes if Cersie had a sword their might not have been a book in the first place. Jaime joined the Kingsgaurd because Cersie was "supposed to" marry Rheagar, thereby keeping them close together as twins and well doing their incesty thing. If Cersie were a knight herself, we're presuming marriage isn't the only route to power and Cersie might have been more content being Lady of Casterly Rock after her Father, and instead kept Jaime by her side, thereby who kills King Aeris? if anyone? Does he succeed in burning Kings Landing to the ground? Hell is Lyanna also a Knight properly, and does she even run away with Rheager in the first place?!
It wouldn't be s the story we all know and love if women were permitted to fight as men do. (There are other fantasy books for that like Farseer Trilogy by Robin Hobb) But tbh this is just a fun AU XD
All the META! Congrats if you made it to the end of my rambling.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Beltizar [2014-05-06 01:08:50 +0000 UTC]
OH LAWD
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
joshthecartoonguy [2014-05-05 14:59:31 +0000 UTC]
Now with 50% less pent up anger!
Here's my critique:
Nice simplification, and excellent color choice. The highlight above her eye distracted me. Eventually I realized it was supposed to indicate her round eye, but it makes her look like she has one light spot of skin above her eye.
On her hands, the forearm of her left hand looks short, and on her left, the sword isn't quite in her hand's grip. The trick I use is to draw a straight line through the inside of the knuckles, and that gives you an idea of where the object would go. Even stylized, the feet are quite tiny. Some armor I've seen actually makes the feet look bigger since they come to that point well past the toes.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
FionaCreates In reply to pica-ae [2014-05-05 23:24:58 +0000 UTC]
Yes, that's where I got the idea. What if she had been allowed to fight instead of discouraged. She's always been more dominant than Jaime, but because of the way their society works Jaime was the one seen to be more powerful. If the dynamic was gone and Cersie was allowed to be dominant in all ways I think it could be terrifying.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
FionaCreates In reply to pica-ae [2014-05-11 17:27:01 +0000 UTC]
well it changes quite a lot. Because if it was socially acceptable to be a female fighter (if the Lannisters were doing it wouldn't everyone copy) Lyanna Stark could have done it in the open, and possibly not run away with Rheagar, who might not even have been married to Elia, it could have been Cersie to begin with! The Rebellion might not have happened in the way that it did if at all, so Brandon Stark would be alive ergo no Ned and Catelyn ergo no Stark kids...
yeah it wouldn't be Game of Thrones as we know it if ladies were acceptable Knights, but that's half the fun XD
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
FionaCreates In reply to pica-ae [2014-05-11 21:14:35 +0000 UTC]
I think part of Brienne's drive is she had no other option in a way. Or felt she didn't.
Like with Lyanna you feel it's a bit like Arya and rebellion but she could have become a powerful figure as Lady Baratheon if she played her cards right. But Brienne's temperament and such and her size and "ugliness" would n ever lead to a good marriage for her, and she found she was good at playing Knight and she had the power and strength to back it up.
I think she would have embraced lady knights but wouldn't have the same opportunities as the ladies from higher houses if that was the case. It's like Jaime Lannister has better opportunities than someone like Ser Donderly or whatever his name is who is the drunk who 'rescues' Sansa.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
yumyumcat [2014-05-05 10:47:48 +0000 UTC]
She does look ready to go off the charts ...that sword is a game changer!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
BretagneMuse [2014-05-05 01:16:10 +0000 UTC]
She would be as utterly ruthless with a sword as she is with verbal barbs and political intrigue- I would personally be very afraid of Cersei with a sword!
I also adore the flowing lines of the red cloak- beautiful!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1