Comments: 44
Depressiveoptimistic [2011-03-23 20:25:34 +0000 UTC]
I love this passage you wrote,it sounds like something ocming out the book
I've just finished where she wrote "No words" before the YELLOW word page c: on Knife edge,every time she thinks of callum or he''s mentioned i almost cry :C it's WAY too emotional!
I hated seeing him get hanged,my heart just dropped reading it :c
Well done!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
rachel-09 [2010-11-21 22:41:17 +0000 UTC]
is this before or after she got the letter from the guard that callum wrote about hating her? just wondering, great piece...and i LOVE the books too.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
GirlAnachronism20 [2010-03-25 18:51:01 +0000 UTC]
awesome! been reading the series over and over for years <3 loved this letter, Sephy was always a little more... pathetic than this after Callum died, which is fair enough! But I like the idea that she could have felt strong and angry about what happened to her.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
dojodragon [2009-07-21 22:19:14 +0000 UTC]
i just finished the book an hour ago. i've never cried at a book but when callum has to choose between his life or his childs i completely broke down.
everything about the book is perfectly timed, written and paced out. i can't find a single falls in malorie blackman's writing.
and your piece is exactly how sephy would feel in a depressed moment. praise for that.
like all the anger callum gathered at time when he was around her passed into her and filled her body with that false rage. congrats, great piece of writing.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ILoveBigCats In reply to dojodragon [2009-07-23 17:14:41 +0000 UTC]
It's a beautiful book... I cried when Lynette and Callum died.
And thanks you ^.^
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
dojodragon In reply to ILoveBigCats [2009-07-23 20:34:49 +0000 UTC]
same. i was welling up all the way through the last chunk of it then when i got to the end of the book, the last thought i had in my head was 'i hate it when jude is right' and then i cried solidly for a good half hour.
anytime hun!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ILoveBigCats In reply to dojodragon [2009-07-23 20:37:24 +0000 UTC]
Have you read Knife Edge/Checkmate/Double Cross? Please say you have, I need someone to discuss Double Cross with...
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ILoveBigCats In reply to Stereofidelica [2009-07-08 15:56:00 +0000 UTC]
Happy too ^_^ Could you critique Dear Doctor, pleases?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Stereofidelica In reply to ILoveBigCats [2009-07-08 16:22:37 +0000 UTC]
I read it, but I honestly have no idea where to start because I can't see anything about it that I'd change. Is there something else you'd like me to critique?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Stereofidelica [2009-07-06 18:42:29 +0000 UTC]
Hmm.
I haven't read the book, but I did read the summary and realize what the letter is about.
In general, I love the piece, though I've never been one for letters between fictional characters. The writing's pretty good and the character is believable.
" I am a shell, empty apart from this thing growing in my womb. I try to imagine the potential joy it could bring, but all I can see is the blood and pain, and everything Mother warned me about. But I’m not scared of the feeling the pain. I’m scared of the numbness enveloping me in its poisonous grey warmth, allowing me to feel nothing but it.
I like the metaphor, but in letters, I think it's more believable and more... comfortable if the tone is conversational, as if the person is speaking to the letter's recipient. If you want to use this figurative language (If you take one glance at my literature in my gallery you'll see I'm figurative language's best friend, so I support it) while making the tone seem believable, try using a simile instead, and limiting your vocabulary. I understand that's a weird direction to give, so I'll try to explain it. People are very rarely able to express emotion and feeling perfectly through words, and they don't often use metaphors either. To make this feel like the tone suits the character more, I think it would be better to explain the character's raw feelings directly and then use a simile to tie them all together. If I re-wrote the first paragraph, it might go like this:
I'm trying to imagine being happy with our child, imagine the joy it could bring, but I can't. All I see is the blood and pain, and everything Mother warned me about. But I'm not scared of feeling the pain. I'm scared of the numbness enveloping me in its poisonous grey cold (I'm wondering why you said "warmth", as I don't think the adjective fits for numbness), not letting me feel anything but numbness. It's like I'm a shell, empty except for this thing growing in my womb.
In this, I changed the metaphor to a simile, and I made sure to use more contractions, because it sounds more like how someone would write in a letter, considering that this letter is a personal letter and not a formal writing piece. I think it fits more in with the character, from what I know of her.
The second and third paragraphs are well-written and more direct, and they feel like the character is speaking. I also like how it gets directly to the point; that's what a letter is for, and you did a good job of communicating the character's feelings and frustration here.
"Does it hurt to read that Callum? Because it hurts to write too. Like Lynette, your father lost hope. As have I".
I like these lines, but I have a couple of things to nitpick on. The first sentence is missing a comma: "Does it hurt to read that, Callum?". You might want to take a look at the next sentence too, "Because it hurts to write it, too.". Adding an "it" and a comma makes it feel better paced. As well, since this is after Callum was hanged, you might want to be careful with characters writing or speaking to dead people, you can do it very well, and you can do it awfully... sometimes it just doesn't feel natural. In this, it's like she's speaking to him directly, and it works, but if you were to write it in a fanfiction where she is the narrator, and she's thinking about him, you should use, "I wonder if it would hurt him, if I ever told him that for real?". In this usage it's comfortable and used pretty well, though.
"Do you remember it, Callum? Do you remember our bodies joining, the forbidden fiery love of Nought & Crosses. I feel can feel it burning, but cold I still remain."
I like this paragraph, but the last sentence is a bit annoying. "cold I still remain". It would be better to use, "I can feel it burning, but I'm still cold inside". It helps communicate the raw emotion instead of the embellished emotion, and it's more realistic. When someone is writing a letter that helps them communicate lots of emotion, it's more natural that they would jump right into the raw emotion and not embellish it with metaphors. Again, use similes for the figurative language.
"The blood has stained my sheets and clothes, a brand of the hatred surrounding our child and everything to do with it. There is too much now. Maybe our child is dying. But we cannot have that. If my child dies, I will crawl into its grave and lay there until I go the same way. If I could do that, I would. Why does no one understand that?"
I absolutely love this paragraph because it's perfectly written, and you found a good balance between the description and the direct emotion. As well, you communicate the emotions of the character better than anywhere else with the "I would..." statement. "If my child dies, I will...". It's a wonderful meeting between explaining the character's feelings directly and not explaining them directly at all; it explains to the reader the emotions of the character without saying one word about them at all.
I like the last line, too, it ties things off very nicely.
Basically, very well-written, it communicates very effectively, but watch you don't sound too angsty by using too much figurative language, and make sure it sounds natural by using contractions. Also, use figurative language sparingly and explain the character's emotion directly more often, then follow it up with a simile or an occasional metaphor.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
sardinescoundrel [2009-04-23 22:14:52 +0000 UTC]
wow! i've never read the book but this is really moving! *fave*
who are the noughts and crosses? terrorists?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ILoveBigCats In reply to sardinescoundrel [2009-04-25 11:49:25 +0000 UTC]
Noughts are white people and Crosses are black people in a society where black people are superior. It's like how America was when the black people were no longer slaves but still treated like shit. Only the other way round.
About the terrorist thing - there are a group of Noughts called the Liberation Militia who fight for the rights of Noughts by blowing stuff up. Callums dad ad brother were both in in, and then Callum joins.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ILoveBigCats In reply to sardinescoundrel [2009-04-26 19:12:20 +0000 UTC]
AWESOME! I could've just lent it you though. Did you get the version wiht 'An Eye for an Eye'It's an amazig book. Depressing, as you'll find out, but amazing.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
sardinescoundrel In reply to ILoveBigCats [2009-04-27 15:23:48 +0000 UTC]
yeah. i 've got that version. nice new display pic by the way.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1