Comments: 8
JuanaSunfall In reply to janach [2017-08-27 20:02:41 +0000 UTC]
Thank you very much, compliments from you mean a lot to me, even if I enjoy our critical discussions all the same.
I agree with you, Sev is a cat-person: quiet, careful, sophisticated , smart, cunning...
I truly understand your opinion regarding the Snarrys. There are certainly more absurd disasters of stories than actual readable ones on the internet, if you like the pairing or not.
Usually I am not into Severus-shippings at all, but this one turned out to be a real treat, and the author really nailed Severus character.
No sparkling, sweet hero with shiny hair at all. Just a snarky potionsmaster with a dark past which he can't forget... for good reasons...
Given that it is an alternative universe, Harry is also not such a douche as in the original story.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
janach In reply to JuanaSunfall [2017-08-27 22:35:04 +0000 UTC]
It's true that Harry has to be completely re-written as a new character to become an acceptable partner for Snape. Hermione, on the other hand, *can* grow and develop from her canon character into a reasonable partner for Severus, if the fanfic author is sufficiently skilled, so I find Snanger generally works better than Snarry. Beautiful and talented Hermione Sue who teaches Severus how to be an agreeable and happy person is, of course, a different matter.
"Home Fries Nazi" works because Harry and Severus both have to learn to deal with having lost their magic. When the story opens Snape has found his solution as a sarcastic, tyrannical short-order cook in a diner in Arizona. Harry, who is nearly suicidal, has to come to terms with the idea that a magic-less life with Snape can be his own solution. Unless he has something as radical as losing his magic to whack him over the head, it's hard to imagine Harry changing enough for Snape to want to have anything to do with him.
By the way, I can also see Severus as a raven or crow Animagus, but a panther is more impressive if we're thinking in terms of competition with the Marauders.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
JuanaSunfall In reply to janach [2017-08-28 13:39:20 +0000 UTC]
Well, Hermione CAN be an acceptable partner for Severus, but I don´t like that pairing either, to be honest. In most of the stories the way she is portrayed is absolutely annoying. The Hermione Granger I know doesn´t grow up to be a perfect, supersexy seductive b*tch who just from one moment to the other finds out that she had always been in love with her former teacher.
The worst fanfics are those were the ministry establishes a marriage-law and decides that the sixteen years old Hermione perfectly fits to her teacher... I mean... really?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
janach In reply to JuanaSunfall [2017-08-28 17:07:31 +0000 UTC]
Marriage Law stories are almost invariably bad, though for some perverse reason I keep looking for good ones. I've seen one or two I like, but they're the kind that subvert the trope. I remember a comic version in which Severus and Hermione are the only ones who end up married because of the law: they spend so much time together working to get the law repealed that they fall in love and marry voluntarily after the issue becomes moot. Another good one is Aurette's "Tattered Man," which ends in tragedy. It really yanks the heartstrings.
Aurette is one of the best SSHG authors around, and she never has Herms pair up with Sev until they're both adults. I especially recommend "Of Muggles and Magic" (Potterverse meets Jane Austen), "Unwritten Future" (time-traveling Herms and 21-year-old Sev defeat the Dark Lord), "Occluded Soul" (Snape tears his soul when he kills Dumbles), "The Caretaker" (a new take on life debts), and "Dark Ages" (Sev becomes a new Merlin after the End Of Civilization As We Know It).
There is one other Snarry story I like: "Pleasant Hope," which just updated yesterday on fanfic-dot-net after a long hiatus. It's an Alternate Universe in which Snape is a stern, guilt-ridden minister in a church in rural Missouri, and at first it appears to be magic-free. But it's not.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0