MagicalJoey [2017-01-11 22:21:45 +0000 UTC]
I will be critiquing this piece on behalf of
Firstly, thank you for your patience with us. I know this piece has been in the folder for a number of years now and your style might have changed/evolved.
Now, the crit:
ST = Stanza
L = Line
It seems fitting that I am critiquing this now, as we have in fact just ushered in another new year.
A few points:
1) Rhyme:
You rhyme well within this piece. Rhyme is inherently difficult to accomplish, and you have accomplished it, for the most part, spot on. You have a variety of types of rhyme within this, though it's all end rhyme. Maybe consider rhyming within the line or rhyming middle lines with each other? It just varies things for the reader to process. I particularly liked the rhyming of 'farce is' in the final ST, as this is not really true rhyme but it still works.
2) Flow and Punctuation:
Because of the good rhyme and meter this piece flows very well. You could have it flow even better by changing your punctuation around a bit though, as at the moment each line ends with a period and is thus very static. Maybe consider adding in some commas or enjambment.
Overall:
I really liked the theme here and you bring it across well. Well done on the rhyme too.
Hope this helps,
Jo
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Pepper-the-phoenix [2014-08-17 01:55:57 +0000 UTC]
Hi! I am critiquing this on the behalf of
I LOVE this piece and completely sympathize. This is how I feel every year, which makes the New Year celebrations particularly painful. I also feel that this is an apt poem for 2014, because God has it been a shitty year. Haha. Over all I really like this poem. i think the rhythm is well done and I like the rhymes. You have really nice word chose and it has a very comical feeling to it, but I also think you capture the absurdity of thinking that things will change just because another year has started. Overall I really enjoyed this poem.
Now, that being said, I only have one suggestion. The last paragraph does not match the rhyming pattern you established throughout the rest of the poem and it feels a little out of place and a little jarring. Also the all in the second to last second seems a little weird to my ear. I'm not even sure you need the all if truth be told.
All in all this is a great piece. Keep up the good work!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0