E-122-Psi [2013-08-07 02:02:56 +0000 UTC]
I think this was something that kinda ruined her SatAm counterpart. I liked how in the show and early media they seemed to have her contrast Sonic, but seemingly to an equal extreme, being meticulous, fussy and dithering over even logical risks (not to mention having a similar bull headedness about it). I liked this idea in concept, two opposites that needed the other to balance them out and compromise.
However the problem was that most of the time, the chemistry was one sided and Sally was usually designated to the Straight Man of the situation with Sonic's approach always being made out to be 'reckless' and 'wrong'. Eventually they just cut the formalities and simplified Sally to being the competent 'always right' character and even when she did screw up it was rarely from her established flaws and more her having a borderline OOC moment, only further implying how unnatural it is for her to act flawed.
I do kinda wish they'd go back to the adorably finicky little prude she was originally and played with it a bit more, making her more Sonic's equal than a generic 'better half' that demeans his key personality.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
PrinceOfQueer [2013-08-06 07:50:26 +0000 UTC]
Although I've grown to be fond of Sally over the past year and a half since joining DA, I think you're right here. She's not one of my favourite characters currently, but I feel if she was used less as the "voice of reason" as you say, that could make her more realistic and more...relatable, I guess? If she was struggling in her role, I'd probably like her a whole lot more.
I do still support the redesign though, and I feel after her roboticisation is over, its the perfect time to develop her character. Surely after being through that you can't come out completely untainted. I'd imagine she'd have some emotional scars and so on.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0