Comments: 10
ziinyu [2011-03-19 18:28:37 +0000 UTC]
Your piece was selected for critique within #ProjectComment 's recent Open Critique chat event. The following is a transcript of the discussion. I like how fuzzy the piece looks - like looking through smoke
I love the image itself. The tiny depth of field is great, and it has a wonderful textured feel to it. The typography on top of it could use some work though.
I really like the perspective of the shot. It makes us feel like the cigarettes and the smoke are right in front of us.
does anyone else think the cigarettes look like those chocolate sticks?
Yeah,and as if the smoke was actually choking us visually,cause we usually can't stand the sight of smoke...
SilverInkblot: Hey,it actually does look like chocolate sticks! LOL
SilverInkblot: Yes, and that's why I think it reads well vertically, "Decadence" to "Suffocate"
but if someone inteprets those cigarattes as chocolate sticks,the message definitely changes....
I actually don't think they look like chocolate sticks
The black and white does wonders on this piece. I don't think it would have as much impact if it was filled with colours
xpedr0: definitely,as I do BW photography myself..
Definitely
I agree
Light/Dark border, thoughts? I'd actually prefer a dark border to further accent the smoke.
ziinyu: argeed
I'm not sure. I think the white border looks really nice with all those grays
Having a black border may make the whole thing look darker but the photo would be unclear though...
I agree
I'd at least tone it down a little bit though to a neutral, as is the border is the lightest part of the image, and pulls unnecessary attention away from the tones in the image.
π: 0 β©: 1
Blackwitch31 [2011-03-19 18:04:43 +0000 UTC]
Hello, I am here on behalf of to post a comment, so let's do it!
Well this work have a message alright, donβt kill yourself!
This is a huge health problem for all of us, and you decided spread it, to advise that the tobacco is very dangerous for us.
The smoke kill us bit by bit, provoking serious damage not only for our lungs but for our brain too.
This sufucate our ideas, our happiness for other words our entire life!
You choose well the subject you know?
π: 0 β©: 0
mumma-duck [2010-07-13 21:57:26 +0000 UTC]
I totally agree!
I hate walking behind someone who's puffing away... nearly kills me til I can get past!!!
Great shot... love the message!
π: 0 β©: 1