fuzzybonnet [2013-11-01 02:13:16 +0000 UTC]
Not bad! I liked the idea, and I really liked the build up after the mom got home. The main thing I would suggest though is to vary your sentences. There was a lot of "She __ ___ __..." I also wish that the trial period was expanded upon a bit, just for flow and better build-up; I had liked the [girl comes home and they talk] section and the [mom comes home without daughter and reflects] part, they flowed well. And I get that the death scene is short and abrupt because that basically matches how the girl was so swiftly taken from the mother's life. But the trial could have something more. The reappearance of the father is probably a big deal, and it would be interesting to see a brief exchange of words to break up the story. You could add some more foreshadowing in there, if you'd like.
It was enjoyable to see how you wrote the mom and the kid, and I think you did that very well-- very genuine. I think the "even you and me?" part sounded a bit forced, but in the end it's fine.
Your writing shone the most during the actual scary part-- starting with the mom coming home alone and reflecting.
I will say that judging by the title and the subject matter, that I had an idea of where the story was gonna go from the start. I don't think it was necessary to have something like the mom saying "he's gonna kill someone one of these days!" because it felt like cold water to the face. Having her shake her head in distaste would be enough if you want her reacting to it; no need to be so obvious.
overall, I liked it. :>
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
miblover334 In reply to fuzzybonnet [2013-11-01 21:04:22 +0000 UTC]
finallly, a good, honest critique! you make some valid points, and i'll keep that in mind for next time. if it seems a little jumbled, that's probably because i wrote this and published in one go, there wasn't much editing or rewriting involved.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0