HOME | DD

selene-chekov — How to Kill a Borg 101 by-nc-nd
Published: 2013-04-18 01:12:24 +0000 UTC; Views: 1394; Favourites: 7; Downloads: 1
Redirect to original
Description The Borg, as we know, is a race of assimilating beings that are a menace to the Federation, and  basically life as we know it. There have been many debates about how to destroy a drone, but no one seems to agree on an answer.

In The Next Generation, it is established that the Borg can adapt quickly to anything that attempts to attack it. Once you shoot them with one type of phaser, you need to change the frequency band to kill another. It’s that fast. But, what they don’t realize is that later on Voyager, the Borg has adapted to even that! Think about it, the Federation has known of them, and they us. Obviously we’ve tried to go drone hunting more than once, right?

Being that it is the 25th Century and life is dandy, they consider our own current type of weaponry primitive. A typical 357 has the range of 50 yards, which is basically a quarter of a mile.  Now what’s the range of a type 3 phaser? Not very far. A phaser, or any type of weaponry the Federation would have is on the construction of electricity. When fired, it will shoot a high concentration of power, which is essentially electrocution.

Everything in fact is based on electricity. Shields of any type are of fluid metal and time electric coils.  Whenever you see Riker or Janeway fire at a drone and that ‘square’ appears, or just a light zap, that’s your shield. The way it works is the little electrons in the metal are floating freely around in the body shield. Computer controlled, when it detects any sort of penetration, it tells the electrons  to quickly ‘hold hands’. (Yes is this is actually possible today.)

Thus preventing the electrical shock through. Now, these shields were designed for electrical currents and whatever the Federation was currently using as hand guns. But  that’s what a it was designed to do, not to stop a speeding bullet. See, metal can pass through the shields because the electric current flows through the lead.

Consider this, if a Borg is an organic life form, despite the technology, they’re alive. What happens when you shoot something in the head? It explodes into bits. Something we refer to as a ‘Kill Shot’. When shooting at close range, or any range, a Borg CAN NOT adapt quickly enough, or at all. Which asks the question; Why don’t they just use Tommy Guns instead of stupid phaser?

Or consider this, on a Borg Drone, there is a common design. Borg Transceiver that connects with the Collective to receive orders from the ‘Hive Mind’. Also, spatial acuity percentiles, or in common words, an advanced eye to perceive things like a single mind. But, there is one donning trait on every Borg. There are connecting tubules all over a drone that run nanites and technological fluids throughout it’s body. Though people aren’t that comfortable being close to Borg, but with a certain amount of gusto, you can kill one without a gun.

Knowing well enough that a knife can cause damage to anyone, a simple cut or severed artery, it is possible it could effect a Borg. Slicing a single tubule could disable one into disorientated stumbling and twitching around for a moment or so then dieing. Sab one in the throat, collapse the inner structure , violá, dead Borg. Yet the question is valid; Why don’t they just switch to ‘primitive’ weaponry?

Which also bears the question, What’s wrong with theses Federation people?

How would Starfleet kill a drone? Panic and run around screaming for the first act at the sight of a Cube. After calming down, they would postulate a theory about what to do. Q may appear, smile and wave at the Captain and watch the crew’s ignorance. Deciding to attack the drones, a team is assembled and phasers remodulated. In the end, a few people may be assimilated, a lesson learned, as well that ends well. right? No. It was the ignorance of the crew that caused the entire episode.

But the answer is clear. They have the replicators to re-create any sort of handgun or rifle. There is the obvious problem of having to reload, but a magazine clip preloaded would be an obvious answer. Though you would have to retrain your crew to not shoot each other, there is a slight disadvantage of flailing bullets.  In short, Starfleet has ignored the idea of the that their ancestors created to assist them in time of need. Of course, the answer is of an opinion, Why didn’t Starfleet just replicate guns and knives to kill Borgs in close combat instead of their primitive phasers?
Related content
Comments: 10

voldemort325 [2013-12-28 16:04:56 +0000 UTC]

Am I the only one ho finds the Borg to be adorable and helpless? Probably... I sort of see everything much differently.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Zoe-the-Pink-Ranger [2013-07-07 16:21:27 +0000 UTC]

According to the DS9 season 8 books, the crew of one of the Starfleet ships in the big Borg battle at the start of First Contact had the prototypes for the TR-116 rifle (the one that was modified with the beaming bullets in the episode 'Field of Fire'). The Borg boarded their ship, adapted easily to their phasers, but were helpless against the rifles with their bullets.
The big problem of going into melee range with the Borg is the greater risk of being assimilated. Even though they seem to be weak against bullets and blades, they just keep coming, and they never tire

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

sir-jase [2013-04-26 13:45:06 +0000 UTC]

I have to go with the deflector argument. However it would be a interesting experiment to see how fast the writers could adapt....

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

GregStitz [2013-04-26 03:54:40 +0000 UTC]

I prefer a sword or mace when fighting them but.....

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

RiseofDarkFire [2013-04-18 16:45:54 +0000 UTC]

I'm not sure your theory about the Borg shielding is correct. Borg ships use adaptive deflector shields, which are used to stop energy weapons and to deflect space debris that would otherwise tear through a ship like light-speed bullets while the ship is at warp. Would it not be efficient for the Borg drones to have the same shielding, only personalized?

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

s3rius In reply to RiseofDarkFire [2013-04-29 18:07:17 +0000 UTC]

It would certainly make sense. But in The First Contact you can see how Picard guns down two drones using a Tommy Gun on the holo deck.

These drones weren't shielded against normal bullets. And I hardly think that Borg would have to "activate" this technology. Even if they had to, the second drone had plenty of time while his friend got gunned down.

Another instance, also in the movie, is Worf killing drones with his Bat'leth (or however you write that). That's comparable to being hit by space debris. Again, the personal drone shields offered no protection.

A reason for that might be that these shields would probably "deflect" any matter that comes into contact with them, similar to force fields.
Which means the drone could not even walk around with his shields active because he's constantly touching the ground.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

RiseofDarkFire In reply to s3rius [2013-05-04 04:11:40 +0000 UTC]

Hm, interesting. You can be sure that all that wouldn't be the case if I were the Borg queen! Walking is overrated anyway. Just give them miniature engines! (They could float through the air like total badasses, like Magneto escaping prison in the second X-Men film.)

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Kalisty-MeMzic [2013-04-18 13:07:19 +0000 UTC]

the answer is because it would be far too intelligent.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Reiko-Foxx [2013-04-18 05:25:22 +0000 UTC]

The most likely case - besides the additional hazards involved in using projectile weapons in a presurized habitat floating in a vacuum with conduits containing who knows what behind any given wall...

Seriously, asthetis aside, a lot of ships in Star Trek should FAIL any reasonable stafety standards given how often episodes revolve around equipment or structural failure! O.O

You know, most races in the star trek universe seem to have forgoten how to employ Safety Engineers... <.<;;

In any event, the most LIKELY case is that the Federations is assuming that:

(A) The Borg can swiftly adapt to our current technology.

means the same as

(B) The Borg can swiftly adapt to technology WE consider primitive.

Basically a mental trap.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

streakpie [2013-04-18 01:42:07 +0000 UTC]

I'm going to guess because that would go agains Starfleet protocol, and that a gun can't be shifted from 'stun' to 'kill'. I guess, even when multiple lives are at stake, Starfleet still tries to hang onto it's humanity and grant the Borg a chance to negotiate or communicate-- even when they know that's a long shot. A long, long shot.

Also, it'd take away from th aesthetics of the universe. xD Storytelling-wise, and all that, mechanics aside. It'd be a pretty boring and un-science fictiony show if Janeway whipped out a pistol whenever the Borg Queen was near.

Besides, by still attempting to be civil to the Borg, they recruited Seven of Nine and the Borg children, right? That's half a step in the right direction, they would rather rekindle lives than end them.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0