HOME | DD

Description

ALRIGHT!!

I've had this theory for quite a while now.
So, y'know how it was mentioned toward the end of Bluestar's Prophecy how Sunstar had contracted an illness that had taken a life or two and left him weak? Then how he lost his last life to a dog? And also how he told Bluefur that StarClan had only given him 8 lives since Pinestar was still alive?
Well, what if someone became aware of Sunstar's shortage of lives after his illness?
Someone who already resented him for choosing Bluefur as deputy?
Thistleclaw.
What if Thistleclaw learned that Sunstar had few lives left and decided to get his revenge for choosing Bluefur as deputy instead of him?
What if it was Thistleclaw who led the dog into ThunderClan territory knowing that the weakened Sunstar would fight it to defend the Clan and most likely die doing so?
That would give an explanation as to 1) why Thistleclaw ended up in the Dark Forest and 2) how Tigerstar learned to use dogs as a method of attack.
Thistleclaw's plan would be to get rid of Sunstar then ambush and kill Bluefur on her way to the Moonstone, then go back to the Clan and claim she was killed by a dog. Then he would likely become leader b/c, like it said in Bluestar's Prophecy, most of ThunderClan thought that Thistleclaw and Bluefur were both the most likely to become leader.
Art @ Skyfirewolf

Characters @ Erin Hunter

DO NOT COPY, TRACE, OR REDISTRIBUTE

Description

ALRIGHT!!

I've had this theory for quite a while now.
So, y'know how it was mentioned toward the end of Bluestar's Prophecy how Sunstar had contracted an illness that had taken a life or two and left him weak? Then how he lost his last life to a dog? And also how he told Bluefur that StarClan had only given him 8 lives since Pinestar was still alive?
Well, what if someone became aware of Sunstar's shortage of lives after his illness?
Someone who already resented him for choosing Bluefur as deputy?
Thistleclaw.
What if Thistleclaw learned that Sunstar had few lives left and decided to get his revenge for choosing Bluefur as deputy instead of him?
What if it was Thistleclaw who led the dog into ThunderClan territory knowing that the weakened Sunstar would fight it to defend the Clan and most likely die doing so?
That would give an explanation as to 1) why Thistleclaw ended up in the Dark Forest and 2) how Tigerstar learned to use dogs as a method of attack.
Thistleclaw's plan would be to get rid of Sunstar then ambush and kill Bluefur on her way to the Moonstone, then go back to the Clan and claim she was killed by a dog. Then he would likely become leader b/c, like it said in Bluestar's Prophecy, most of ThunderClan thought that Thistleclaw and Bluefur were both the most likely to become leader.
Art @ Skyfirewolf

Characters @ Erin Hunter

DO NOT COPY, TRACE, OR REDISTRIBUTE