Dediggefedde [2012-07-18 22:01:40 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Hello again! As I see, this is another great photo-manipulation of yours, however, not as good as the other one in my opinion.
But as you probable want to hear a bit more in-detail I will give you a more detailed reason of my ratings:
To talk about the first thing, the vision, I still don't think, that porcelain is that feminine, steampunk that masculine, and also miss some major contrast-expression within your picture, however this time, when I get the message right, I can see how the girl has similar face-attributes like little birds and her posture seems to be also very light. So, now I would say, as I can find the second point of your description within this picture, 4/5 stars for vision.
Regarding originality, this picture has his great strength. you can see the birds resemble steampunk and the posture, the broken clock, its design and position, the numbers on her shirt and of course the smoke are really some original elements nicely put together.
So 5/5 stars for originality.
Well, talking about technique, the background seems kind of off here just like the clock. So, for a photo-manipulation where you try to melt different elements to a new piece, this seems more like glued together in these aspects.
However, I really like the smoke-effect and editing of the different elements, so I hope 3.5/5 stars for technique would be appropriate.
Regarding impact this piece has a lot less tension than the other one and the clock that doesn't seem to fit takes a bit of impact away, too... So, without much objective reasoning, as I don't seem to can do that while writing about impact, I would give you 3/5 stars for impact.
So, concluding, this is another great piece of you with some little fields of improvement in technique and impact as said above, but nonetheless a great photo-manipulation!
You are receiving this critique as you submitted your art into #TheSp0t 's critique-folder. I hope it is helpful!
a.deviantart.net/avatars/t/h/t⦠" alt=" " title="TheSp0t"/>
π: 0 β©: 0