Comments: 16
silverfleckedlullaby [2011-08-19 18:50:18 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
This is definitely a deviation from your usual style, and that, in my opinion is always a good thing in my opinion. It's not as...beautiful, or lyrical or sensuous as your other poetry, nor does it employ dense imagery, and oddly its forte is really its tone and rhythm, despite its rather rough feel.
The words you use are commonplace and stark and upfront--it's like someone demanded you to strip your content bare of fancy rhetoric, and yet there is rhetoric, plenty of it. Anyway, I'm going to take this stanza by stanza, and to hell with the star ratings.
The second person address, as always, draws the reader in and forms the initial connection between writer and reader. For some reason, the second line made me think of clotheslines, and I almost expected that to pop up somewhere in the first stanza. I don't quite like the "on a line, on a series of lines," probably because you don't really create an image that's striking enough to be adequate for the "peeled apart and dissected and laid bare." Those are powerful, powerful words, and "a series of lines" simply doesn't come close to being adequate for them. I love that last line there, the gutted feeling it gives rise to, and I love it all the more because the repetition of the "and" gives it a relentless rhythm.
Now, the first stanza normally sets the tone for a piece, and the mood till now has been one of being ripped apart--it's not a peaceful mood. Yet, the second stanza is soft, and the lack of transition is disconcerting. I'm not sure if it is meant to be so, but it felt a little rough and disjointed, as if the first few lines were part of another poem altogether. The imagery in the second stanza--and this is the first time I've ever felt this way about your writing--is rather weak. Now, I'm being extremely blunt, and really, if it were anyone else writing this, it would be passable, but knowing your level of skill, I would expect a little more originality, a little more style, a little more flavour, if you know what I mean. Yes, the content paints an image, yes, it creates an impact, but it could do more.
The third stanza feels more in tandem to the first stanza, and its imagery, combined with the sounds of the words, make it far more powerful than the second stanza. The several caesuras only magnify the impact. However, there were a few places where I thought the rhythm felt a bit off-kilter--I felt as if "between its heart and lungs" would do better without the "its" and "suddenly expanding" would sound better as "expanding suddenly." I also feel that the lines"just before one moment touches the next...built again" were a bit iffy, and would benefit from a bit of restructuring. "as their molecules fly apart" could use a more striking verb. Brilliant use of the line break, though, in the last line of the stanza--you had me holding my breath.
The fourth stanza's content has so much meaning to it that if you had used more imagery in it, it would have been a sensory overload--but you haven't done that, and it works perfectly. "find yourself/ living in increments" is sheer brilliance, and the staccato feel of the short sentence fragments amplifies, as intended, the fragmented spellbound sort of feeling. I kind of felt "the universe's steady heartbeat" would sound better as "the steady heartbeat/ of the universe,"
but that's pure nitpicking. I prefer "(ex)pressing" over "pressing," personally; it's more intriguing.
I like the first line of the last stanza as it is, and the first half of the second line...and I kind of prefer a mix of your previous version and this version, where you keep the parts I mentioned, and then bring in the "we cannot punch...ourselves from sleep" and then "keep your eyelids...cheeks" and then the "time rolls through us...dying," but meh, I'm not too sure.
Overall, the last line has as much impact as the first few lines of the poem, and yes, this piece is stunning in its own way--no piece by you could be otherwise--but it needs a bit of polishing in my opinion. Hope this was of help to you (and I hope it wasn't too blunt)! e.deviantart.net/emoticons/h/h… " width="15" height="13" alt="" title="Heart"/>
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Wataqo [2012-01-16 10:35:03 +0000 UTC]
I realize it's been several months since you posted this, but I'm putting in my two cents.
I really really really like this poem. I was feelin it, man. Riiight up until that last stanza. Your previous final stanza looks like it'd work a lot better with some work - its brief words and simple language don't really match the rest of the poem, but the transition from the imagined and reality is made a heck of a lot smoother by that first line, "keep your eyelids pinned to your cheeks". Buckle up, kids. We're gonna go cash a reality cheque.
With the current one, you switched it up and I didn't even notice until I finished and reread the stanza.
Also, I don't like the parentheses. The first set looks out of place and breaks the flow. And to me it breaks the pattern of "Imagine this", "Imagine your memories" and "Imagine time". As for (ex)pressing... okay, nevermind that's a nice touch. Regressing serves as a great counterpart for either and each holds its own message.
Neither the parentheses nor the last stanza would stand out as much if it weren't for how captivating the rest of the poem is though. Again, I really like. Thanks for sharin.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
spoems [2011-12-10 19:52:53 +0000 UTC]
Very engaging scene building.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
MysticFay [2011-12-09 07:39:37 +0000 UTC]
I liked this. I have no comment on the mechanics; it seems like have enough feedback on that. I felt like I was flying through a dream as I read this, and I quite enjoyed the ride.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
escap-ing [2011-10-22 14:37:29 +0000 UTC]
this is so amazing. i'm so glad i'm following you. (:
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
RiseandBe [2011-10-11 18:21:34 +0000 UTC]
I really loved the ending. It tied it all together for me.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
archelyxs [2011-08-27 02:43:44 +0000 UTC]
The sixth stanza
is truly transcendental
and I wish I could say more
so this is placeholder text
for the compliments and worthwhile comments
I'd like to bestow on this fine work
at a time when i'm not so tired
and thinking about sleep and salt
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
irvon [2011-08-19 15:32:35 +0000 UTC]
I love the idea of this poem, exploring the smallest step of time. I love lines like "not a stutter / but a pause", and the entire second stanza ("imagine you memories") is breath-taking. However, there are a few things that could be better, in my opinion.
There is fairly little connection between the first stanzas and the rest of the poem, as separated by the sentence in brackets. I love seeing a poem come full circle, by referring to "your life strung out / on a line" again, for example.
The enjambments feel a bit random at times. Whether it's for meter, for meaning or for surprise, a sparing use of enjambments is always better, because now I sort of ignored them and read on. Looking back on the poem, though, I see a lot of good ones as well ("everything / free-floating" and "find yourself / living in increments" are especially awesome). Think hard about which ones you really need.
The edit of the closing stanza makes it much better, but it is still not the smack in the face that a long poem like this one needs.
All in all, this is a good poem that could be great with some editing.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
palaeochannel6 [2011-08-18 03:26:12 +0000 UTC]
Beautiful. Read it a few times, it just stole my attention and heart.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Red-banner [2011-08-16 15:39:57 +0000 UTC]
This poem is absolutely breath-taking. I don't have a critique, but every single line since "imagine time / forgetting to breathe" is gradually more awesome-in-the-old-sense.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0