Comments: 22
SpiritseekerDA [2017-01-10 20:56:28 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Hello! I found this piece through Project Comment, and I've been meaning to critique it. To start, I really like the clean coloring and shading. Despite the slight graininess that is expected with any traditional art, it is very smooth and very well done! The lines are also something I'd like to comment on. They are almost expertly done, the only thing I'd say is to vary the line thickness to add interest to the picture. The flaw with this picture are minimal, but common mistakes. There are slight anatomy errors, such as in the jaw, pinky, and the size of the nose (which is a bit too small). The whole picture seems to be leaning a bit, which can usually be fixed by paying attention to specifically that aspect or having someone else look at it for the purpose of spotting that. Others said that you forgot his sharingan, but it isn't really noticeable unless you're looking for it. The last bit of advice I'd like to give is to create your own image, though I haven't taken a thorough look through the rest of your gallery so I don't know if this was just a "for fun" drawing which you only did once or twice. That's it, this is honestly a great drawing, and your Copic technique is very good!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Gareque In reply to SpiritseekerDA [2017-01-10 23:15:06 +0000 UTC]
Thank you for the compliments . Wish I saw my own work in the same light lol!
I actually saw a video regarding varying thickness in the line art after I'd set this down and started colouring it, so I'll be looking at that for my next piece .
Strangely, I found a lot of people seem to be commening that the colouring is smooth, yet this is what I find to be weakest when I look back at it, as it appears patchy to me and I can see it glaring at me! It was however my first time ever using Copics.
Making my own physical artwork is something that's eluded me thus far as I can never get it right. I can take an image in most mediums and replicate it to some level, if not as well, but making my own from it I seem to fall apart before I've even begun...
That said, I've been forcing myself to learn actual anatomy and as a result I'm making headway on a Hisoka image I am doing while on lunch at work. The image itself is taken from a screenshot, but as a new step for me, I am drawing it entirely from memory, the only time I've looked at a source image was to see roughly how high above his hairline his hair actually peaks.
It's not a perfect image, but as it's the first time in over a decade even attempting something from memory, (and only having drawn his face once before) I am quite pleased! I'll be putting that up soon as a WIP.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
SpiritseekerDA In reply to Gareque [2017-01-10 23:32:52 +0000 UTC]
If you're looking at drawing your own original figures, looking at guidelines for people and stock images are the best way to do so. Rough sketches are a good way to quickly practice anatomy, and to get something anatomically correct can be as easy as just doing a sketchy outline. Also, sketching people and trying to get their pose sketched correctly before they move is a fun exercise to help improve speed once you've got the basics down. I'd also recommend getting a few how to draw books that have step-by-step processes starting from the guidelines. I'm sure if I thought for a long time I could come up with more tips for faster improvement, but that's all I can come up with off the top of my head! Thanks for the reply, and have a nice evening! (It's about 6 pm here so, sorry if you aren't in the same timezone)
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Chameleonist [2017-01-07 01:08:54 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
IT'S KAKASHI!!! >w<
Hiyas! I found your art through ProjectComment ~
Kakashi is probably my second-favourite Naruto character, after Sasuke, but who doesn't love Sasuke? Anyway, I have a lot of things to say about this picture, and only a few of them are bad. ^n^ I'll start with some bad, because everyone knows bad news should come first.
I'm sure it's no surprise that some of the proportions are off. Don't worry too much; it happens to everyone. The big one is the hand; I would suggest doing some anatomy studies on hands to get them more accurate, and use plenty of references, like the picture you based this on. Also, keep in mind the fact that, in general, a hand is just smaller than the face.
In contrast, that kunai is freaking awesome! It's remarkably straight for a traditional drawing; I envy your ability to draw straight lines. XD
The nose could be done a little better, but all things considered, it's pretty good; I didn't even notice it at first. Of course, I was distracted by the hand, but you know. Same goes for the eyes; try doing some studies on eyes and practice pointing them in different directions so you get a feel for how eyes work, and the rest will start to come naturally.
Overall, you did a fantastic job, and you've got plenty of space for improvement, so keep working at it!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Gareque In reply to Chameleonist [2017-01-07 01:18:15 +0000 UTC]
Thanks for the critique .
Hands are one of my banes lol, I always struggle there. But then, I was previously struggling with the facial feature alignments etc and am showing improvements there, so I am happy with that at least!
I have only started doing manga style art in the past few months so things like the shading on noses is something I am still trying to get right .
Problem with the Kunai is I can see the lining beneath the shading . It took me a about 3 lines to get it as straight as I wanted it, but I still didn't think it was straight enough, so thanks for the compliment there!
Regarding the show, honestly, I've never seen it (I know, I'll hang my head in shame). I've only recently gotten in to Anime after watching Death Note, so know nothing of the characters. I did this as a character study as a friend requested a piece done of him, so I wanted to get a feel for it .
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Chameleonist In reply to Gareque [2017-01-07 01:34:21 +0000 UTC]
Ooohhh... I see. I actually haven't watched it either; I read the manga. XD I always prefer the manga to the anime, because I read faster than typical anime pacing. But if you enjoyed Death Note, I have a feeling you'll like Naruto; it has a lot of dark elements that you might miss on the first pass. Especially considering (not-so spoiler) Naruto's parents are dead, and it constantly comes back to that fact. It's a really good story, though, and once you get into it, if you ever do, you'll understand why I love Kakashi so much~
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Chameleonist In reply to Gareque [2017-01-07 01:47:17 +0000 UTC]
Haha! Well, from what little I remember of what I've read of Bleach, you picked a good one. I would go back and read it properly from beginning to end, buutttt.... I like yaoi too much. >w<
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Zazoreal [2017-01-07 20:09:40 +0000 UTC]
quick question. do you rotate your page when you draw? or do you keep it straight up? some people tend to draw lines at certain angles a bit more skew. This only goes away with practice and control. so most people that draw skew lines like the ones I see in this picture tend to keep the page straight up. When you draw lines straight down you tend to bend them towards your left, which in turn makes the whole pose look like it's leaning towards the left of frame in the bottom half and some top parts. You have talent, But talent can only become a great talent with practice.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Zazoreal In reply to Gareque [2017-01-07 22:48:06 +0000 UTC]
I would say the best way to straighten out your form and line work is just watch tutorials on poses and dynamic figures. Be sure to grab a pencil and do quick sketches of the poses shown in those tutorials. Another question. How fast do you create lines? Do you use strokes or move more slowly? If you use strokes more often, then practice slow line work and vise versa. Here is another great way to improve. "HANDS" they are pretty damn hard and are good practice for line work of all kinds. Here is a nice tutorial.
Hope this helps.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=xV3Pmb…
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Gareque In reply to Zazoreal [2017-01-07 23:16:44 +0000 UTC]
Thanks for the link and certainly something I can use with the Hisoka WIP I have atm!
I tend to use a mix of single strokes and multiple. I will typically sketch out an under image with very rough linework to get the shape and once I feel I have that, I will put it in place more heavily or with ink. Lately I have been trying to train my ability to put a straighter single stroke down.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
RcTheNatural [2017-01-06 08:24:10 +0000 UTC]
awesome work!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1