PuddlesOfCuddles [2012-02-03 19:00:43 +0000 UTC]
First glance - I certainly do not read the message you're trying to portray. I don't get sushi from this anywhere at all
How opposed are you to trying a different composition?
My main issues with this piece, is your subject matter seems to have a much too calm of a gesture to be supporting something so fatal, and dangerous. In addition, there aren't a lot of narrative elements. It's hard to read what this is about when we have a character (their design matters, but not too much to work with), their pose, and their expression. Generally more characters/environment/objects will help in the story telling sense.
Sadly, your topic is a bit on the difficult side to portray. I've been attempting to think of some ways to portray this... Eh, let's just do some spit-balling.
What's the goal? The audience needs to understand that sushi is killing off fish. Not just "fish," but certain fish, endangering only some. Using a mermaid as a representation is pretty good, just be careful that this is more aimed toward a propoganda sort of view, and not just a pinup/gore thing.
I suggest adding exotic/rare fish in the background in some way - perhaps do a bit of research, I'd imagine you can caricature their beauty if need be - you're really good at that. This way, the audience can see that this isn't simply an image about a mermaid, there are a lot of rare/endangered things.
We need to incorporate sushi - or your point won't be read at all. An obvious route would be to have a mermaid cut up into pieces arranged so we can tell it's a mermaid on a platter of sushi. This route takes care of our problems, yet ends up being possibly gorey and disturbing (Also, a bit unoriginal). I wonder if there's some way to just draw a huge-ass sushi, such that it takes up like, 4/5ths of the canvas, and inside you could have a mermaid/other various creatures in distress... I foresee readability issues...
Maybe, this image could take place in the ocean. Atop of the water, we'll see a boat, with some famous sushi house logo on it. The audience will see the boat pulling up a large net, where exotic fish/the mermaid will be held captive - suffering etc.
My point is - you don't have enough elements to portray your point. She looks absolutely gorgeous - but it turns into more of a pinup then anything.
I like your point that sex sells, but if you're going that route - don't sell it for sex-sake. This timid-back-only stuff sells, but in a provocative way - Like, it's too planned, and too erotic. If you were going with the boat/netted fish idea, having her facing the audience, maybe three-quarters or something; the mermaid would not be concerned who's watching if her chest is showing. Sex sells, but beauty is easier for the audience to be captivated by - that and they won't be distracted to your narrative.
Whattya think? I'll happily keep bouncing ideas with you!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
KDdreamer In reply to PuddlesOfCuddles [2012-02-03 21:10:45 +0000 UTC]
[link] here's the article the piece is for.
I agree. Sushi isnt reading as well as I would like it. If it were in color, I think it would a little more. The pieces on her back are assortments of sushi, mainly, pieces of what the article focuses around.
"The Toxic Five" are the 5 main fish that are being affected because of mass need for sushi.
Erotic Sushi is traditionally presented on the front of a woman, but I felt like that was too provocative for the article, so I stuck to a bare back instead.
She's sitting on a sushi chopping block, but you're right. It needs more elements that read "Sushi" and focuses on the problem.
What if I added her tangled in a net on her fin, then an assortment of cutting knives and ingredients for sushi near the block?
Do you think the mermaid is just too much?
👍: 0 ⏩: 0