Admiral-Awesome [2008-08-08 09:53:26 +0000 UTC]
I actually really like this. Some of the lines in there are just beautiful.
"Unfailing, untarnished, alive in our hearts"
"A country with a future as great as its past "
Those are both wonderful ideas and extremely well put into words. They both have great imagery and the unfailing line has an excellent rhythm to it.
I think it doesn't need to rhyme, but a few little tweaks could perfect it.
Umm... For a start 'The echoes calls us' should either be echo calls us or echoes call us.
The third line has a rhythm issue, I'd instead write "Sun silently crosses this Great South Land." The syllables fit better and I think the alliteration has more punch.
Personally I'd drop 'our ANZAC' from the fourth line, as it gives the sentence a slightly better structure.
Oh and I'd put a the in the wonders line, as in 'Rich in the wonders'
I think that's it. Change whatever you like, and feel free to ignore me completely if that suits you. I'm sorry for the power critique, its just I really like this poem and think it could be really special if you spent a little more time with it.
Anyways, well done, I really like this. Awesome stuff.
You're a long comment.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Kill--Hawk In reply to Admiral-Awesome [2008-08-08 12:51:23 +0000 UTC]
That's some power commenting. Do you mean make the line 'the echoes of heroes...'? And I did initially have something similar to your sun silently suggestion, but the silently is meant to apply to the next line, about the ANZACS. So "as the sun crosses... the echoes silently call us..." which is where a lot of issues came from..
I'll make some of those improvements now!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0