Comments: 15
Maxedrox [2016-09-13 03:36:12 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
About your story, it makes me confuse about what really is going on between those two characters, first the blue guy wants to buy the horse, but a few comments later I wants a challenge, so.. At least the horse is the price of the challenge? And the other guy reject sell the horse, but then he accept the challenge, again whitout any fear to lose his horse? The blue guy could domate the horse and escape whit it, that could be a very nasty twist, but well I guess that I need more story for the final conclusion. About the art itself, I really admire your effort in it, very, very dedicated to the colors, the shadows, its just, incredible, but your technique falls in the dimention of the characters, you try to bring the 3d scent whit the shadows and the colors, but some detaills like weird looking of the arms, posture (look when the guy put his hand on his horse) the three fingers of the blue guy in one frame, the weird perspective of the blue guy in another frame (second frame) you can work on that, you can try to use the models of anime and manga, those that appear to "how make a face" you will see a circle whit some lines, those lines has their uses, and is be a guide for the perspective of the character, there is some for the body too, but I think, if you fix the face, you can easy fix the body later. So I dont have any doubt about your skills n_n
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
LuckyStarhun In reply to Maxedrox [2016-09-13 08:13:46 +0000 UTC]
Thank you for your critique! I agree with you about the story, but I intended it to be two pages only. It is hard to tell exactly what is going on in two pages, as the characters are from two different worlds (the ble guy is not my character, it is from another artist's series, the red guy and the horse are my own characters. They all have their background stories not told here, the knowing of which could have helped you understand the story. Of course it's understandable that one cannot instantly understand the meaning from such a short story. (In fact the red guy does not really want to sell the horse and the other one does not want to buy it, the main focus is on the bet - I could have just left the selling part out, you are right. Also, this specific horse would be very hard to escape with, it broke out from a lab and is extremely hard to ride because he shrugs everybody off and is not very controllable.) So it's kind of a crossoverish thing, not a story with a continuation. After the scene the characters both continue their virtual lives in their respective worlds.
I agree with you on the anatomy flaws, I have to practice more. However, it's not the second frame where the perspective is weird, but the first. The second frame is how I intended it, in the first frame the two guys are not lined up. So the second frame is the reference
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
FelonDog [2016-09-11 21:49:28 +0000 UTC]
Your humans look fantastic! I love how expressive they are.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
neko-comix [2016-09-09 18:59:57 +0000 UTC]
he is going to regret riding that horse,i bet
👍: 0 ⏩: 1