HOME | DD

wierdgirlwhodraws In reply to Calenator [2014-02-23 23:58:14 +0000 UTC]

He probebly is but Rapunzal yearns to learn more about the world and is extremely creative

👍: 0 ⏩: 2

Marilia-Barbosa In reply to wierdgirlwhodraws [2014-10-15 03:52:07 +0000 UTC]

Hiccup also yearns to learn more about the world and is extremely creative and innovative as well. I think he's more Ravenclaw than Rapunzel. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

wierdgirlwhodraws In reply to Marilia-Barbosa [2014-10-16 13:21:23 +0000 UTC]

this is very true but I personally find Hiccups Hufflepuff traits to stand out more then Rapunzel's do such as his sense of fairness and loyalty while Rapunzel has them Hiccup shows them a lot more then she does but eh your opinion is your opinion mine is my opinion all is fair in the world ^.^



I also may be a tad biased being a Hufflepuff myself ^.^'

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Marilia-Barbosa In reply to wierdgirlwhodraws [2014-10-18 02:54:18 +0000 UTC]

I'm probably a Hufflepuff too, though I never took a test or anything... 

Everyone has their opinions, though I really don't think Hiccup shows more Hufflepuff's traits than Revenclaws, meanwhile, I think Rapunzel shows a lot more of Hufflepuff's than Revenclaw's. Besides, he also shows traits of his personality that goes against Hufflepuff's, actually. 

I think he has a good fairness sense, but I don't agree with the loyal part, and before you start rolling your eyes, let me tell you why. For me, Hiccup is much more trusting than loyal. There is a fine line that differs them, but there is a difference, being trusting is not the same thing as being loyal. 

I wouldn't sort him in Ravenclaw just because he's smart, a Ravenclaw is not just that and a Hufflepuff is not only loyal and hardworking.

So here is a bit of why I think he shows more of the blue house traits: Ravenclaws are inventive, innovative, creative (just look at all the weapons he was making to compensate his lack of strength or Toothless's prosthetic tail fin), they are usually individualistic (he often spend afternoon in the forest, even before he met Toothless, as Gobber said when talking to Stoick in httyd, he is fine by himself or with Toothless's company), they usually look forward, to the future, instead of sticking to the past and traditions (even thought he tried to be one of the Vikings, when he realized he trulywasn’t and the truth about the dragons, he immediately changed his mind without even hesitating), they not usually tolerates stupidity (just think about the twins and Snotlout, specially in the tv series), they are clever and wit, discoveries excite them and they’d go out to know something even if it’d take some risks (he went after a Night Fury that could have killed him easily, that’s actually why I think if he was really a Hufflepuff, he might not do that and the movie’d just not exist). And the element of this house is air, witch I think it suits him a lot more than earth.

Besides, I think that even if Rapunzel was so eager to see the world, she'd have gone out even before she met Flynn/Eugene, even if it was just to wonder aground next the tower, she never went because she was too afraid of taking risks and because she was too loyal to her "mother" to disobey her. She's also not too innovative, inventive or anything (just creative because she's an artist), in fact, a Hufflepuff trait is being "home-y", even though Rapunzel wanted to see the world because she was locked up in a tower for 18 years, she liked to stay in her home, she said it right at the beginning of the movie to Pascal. I also think she shows a lot more of her loyalty than Hiccup, like when she sacrificed herself to save Eugene at the end of Tangled (sacrificing for other is also a Hufflepuff trait). But, again, it's just my opinion, you don't have to agree, just keep an open mind to other's opinions. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

wierdgirlwhodraws In reply to Marilia-Barbosa [2014-10-18 13:05:58 +0000 UTC]

this is all very true but can we just agree to disagree? I have my opinion you have yours and that's fine ^^ good explanation btw I can really see why you think they would be in those houses (I'm terrible at explaining things XD)


also im not the one who made this (I don't even have Photoshop)

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Marilia-Barbosa In reply to wierdgirlwhodraws [2014-10-18 15:01:49 +0000 UTC]

Just trying to make my point, I know people has different opinion, it's just that it's sadden me a little when people forget Hiccup's cleverness and creativity... I've read a few fics that Hiccup is put in Hufflepuff and is just pictured as a stupid boy. Not the twins or Snotlout's level of stupidity, but stupid nonetheless... 

and oops... sorry, usually the people who answers are the ones who owns it, so I kinda forgot to pay attention... lol... 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

wierdgirlwhodraws In reply to Marilia-Barbosa [2014-10-18 17:00:15 +0000 UTC]

fair enough :3 but just letting you know that I would NEVER forget Hiccup's cleverness of AWESOME!
also stupid fanfics making us huffles looks stupid >n<

hmm maybe one of the reasons I picture Hiccup as a Hufflepuff is cos of the books.... despite the two Hiccups being entirely different people... hmmmm... I mean he isn't stupid in the books if anything he's MORE intelligent then movie Hiccup but hmmmmmmmmmm

ah its fine don't worry bout it ^o^

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Marilia-Barbosa In reply to wierdgirlwhodraws [2014-10-18 20:01:13 +0000 UTC]

Me too! I hate how people put Hufflepuff's as stupid. I man, look at Cedric, he was a Hufflepuff, but he was smart too! 

From the books, I think he is also much more a Ravenclaw than a Hufflepuff, even though he doesn't work in the forge and is not as inventive as movie Hiccup. I agree that in the books he is even more clever, he is always the one making plans and always figuring out everything, I like his character in the books as well, though I fell in love with the movie first! 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

wierdgirlwhodraws In reply to Marilia-Barbosa [2014-10-18 20:57:59 +0000 UTC]

AND MEH! >:3 ........actually never mind -o-' im no smarty :I

really? cos i think he's even more Huffle in the books and yes while he is smarter then movie Hiccup
Book Hiccup is ALOT more loyal and trusting and second chance giving and he has a REALLY strong sense of fairness
he's also working hard towards making the world a better place despite everything going against him (and there is ALOT going against him ;m although that might be more Gryff then Huffle
he also has a lot of Raven Traits and even atleast one Slyth trait (Cunning) but i feel his hufflepuff traits are strongest and the reason he has to be clever cunning wise and brave is because his Hufflepuff traits are putting him in situations where he needs to be all that (the shit he has to go through ;n; and all the books so far a before he's the age Movie Hiccup was in film one!!!! D'

again this is my opinion though so feel free to disagree ^^ its just while i ADORE the movie the books will always be better to me and yeah :I

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Marilia-Barbosa In reply to wierdgirlwhodraws [2014-10-19 15:18:41 +0000 UTC]

He indeed show a lot of the Hufflepuff traits in the books, still, I don't know, I think that the traits he shows are also Ravenclaw's.

Not only because he's freaking smart(er) in the books, and yes, he doesn't invent or create anything there, but if you see, he shows that he's very curious and eager to know more, to discover, to learn. He is always the one planing everything. He likes reading and he's always interested in new stuff. He managed to learn languages by just observing, that probably is a sign of how dedicated to knowledge he is, or at least that is what I think. He also have a passion for knowing more, and those things characterize Ravenclaw's as well, and, in my opinion, those traits are more outstanding than his loyal-hardworking side. About the sense of fairness, with what I've read in analyses of the houses, is something that can fit perfectly the blue house as well. 

BTW, he definitely is very cunning (Slytherin) in both the book series and the movie's universe, but he also have a big of Gryffindor, since he's courageous and brave, in both universes. 

For me, is quite the opposite, his Ravenclaw's traits are stronger and the reason for him to do everything (in the books or in the movies) is because of his cleverness and quick thinking, which characterizes more the Raven's. He's cunning because he's clever, he's often courageous because he's always planing ahead, and such stuff... Maybe his Hufflepuff traits put him in some situations, like when he was trying to save Fishlegs (I forgot the number of the book), but if it wasn't for his Ravenclaw's traits, he probably wouldn't survive book 1 (I mean, really, have the idea to put the two giant dragons the way he did was a very nice plan! And I think that planning and having leading skills are more Raven's than Huffle's). 

That is just my opinion, you also don't have to agree with them, like I didn't agree with yours, but I think it is nice to have a good and civilized disagreeing conversation without swearing or anything like it. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

wierdgirlwhodraws In reply to Marilia-Barbosa [2014-11-07 00:18:21 +0000 UTC]

I suppose in both the books and the films he is equally Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw so I guess what really matters when sorting him is oppinion
not just our opinions either HCCUP's opinion on which he values most. he may have both traits but it all depends on which traits he values the most
I myself do have traits from houses other then Hufflepuff but other then Creaivity (which I think is more ravenclaw) I don't value them nearly as much
as my Hufflepuff traits and there are a few Huffle traits I don't have but still value and wish I did have them (coughhardworkingnesscough)
so really if you think about it while his Huffle traits might stand out more to Hufflepuffs and his Claw traits might stand out more to Ravenclaws but
it all depends on Hiccup really and as much as I would like to think I do I don't know either Hiccups well enough to know which one he would
value more. I know which one he would CHOOSE (Ravenclaw) but I don't think you can just choose
(Harry probably still would be Gryff even if he didn't ask not to be in Slyth it would have just taken the hat longer to figure that out)
but again this is all my opinion  

also you have read all the Books? I want to bring up a point that may include spoilers ^^'


yes it is nice to have a civilised conversation like this  now if only all arguments(if you could even call this an argument) over small things were like this


PS I forgot to mention he is very Modest in the books (not really in the films) and modesty is a very Hufflepuff trait

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Calenator In reply to wierdgirlwhodraws [2014-02-24 05:04:24 +0000 UTC]

I guess

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

starseed31 In reply to supivuokko [2013-08-21 20:12:00 +0000 UTC]

If don't like it then ignore it or don't come here.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0