Comments: 21
TheLastHetaira [2012-07-09 23:40:07 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Another piece to critique? Sure, why not? You actually have some quality to your writing, and I can tell you put your heart and soul into your work. Let's proceed, shall we?
First of all, I absolutely love that you add a realistic edge to your Pokemon world. Yes, Pokemon and people can die. Manure occurreth, and in this case, it totally turns the protagonist's life upside-down. The typical "trainer on a journey" is replaced with someone who turned down that path for, in the end, many reasons. That alone is pretty refreshing. The TF aspect is secondary. This is one of your stronger suits, so keep going with it.
Again, however, be careful of the orphan/dead parent situations. Yes, deaths in the family happen, and yes, you do them very well, but don't use them as a crutch. If this happened in, say, a world where people got devoured my monsters on a regular basis, I could understand its prevalence. That said, props for the mundane death via car accident; it could happen to anyone, which makes the audience sympathize with the character. You do deaths in the family pretty well, but be careful of overusing it. I look forward to seeing what you do with the embodiment of Mesprit, since apparently that's something different.
(I'm tempted to ask: Does a parent dying touch you on a personal level, by any chance? You don't have to answer if you don't want to. There are people who nix the parents out of convenience, then there are people who know what it's like; ether you fall firmly into the latter box or you have a very good sense of the consequences that losing a loved one can have. )
As the previous critic pointed out, yes, padding your dialogue with body language might be a good idea. The less one's story reads like a script, the better. Plus, you could totally have fun with the sprites. e.deviantart.net/emoticons/s/s… " width="15" height="15" alt="" title=" (Smile)"/>
Finally, grammar. I addressed this in my previous crit. The same still applies. All you need is practice and a good editor.
Stars and reasons:
Vision: What can I say? I don't think anyone's done this before. What could've been a 'normal' Azelf TF was tossed out in favor of a touching story with sympathetic characters and a tie to the canon.
Originality: Even if Azelf TF's have been done before, this one is handled so well that I'm willing to 5/5 it.
Technique: Again...you need a good grammar book. I'd be totally willing to workshop something with you on GDocs just so that these things can be hand-fixed. Clearly spell-check is not enough.
Impact: Even with my criticisms, this still packs a wallop. I want more.
Verdict: Put it this way: I'm not a fan of the Lake Trio and I liked this. I'd be honored to collab on something with you at some point; even with all of your grammar mistakes, I've seen a lot worse, and you have that creative spirit that I'd like to see more often. Bravo.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
personqwer [2012-04-26 23:08:59 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Ok, time for a beautiful critique I have for you and your wonderful story.
The beginning explaining Andrew's backstory was very smooth, and as the story progressed practically each part easily slid into another and the beginning, middle, and end each tied into one another perfectly. One suggestion though, when Azelf, Mesprit, and Uxie were talking at the end, I would have added a little more detail to that. Use body language when they're communicating as well- not that you didn't at all, you did. but I would have done that more. For example, since Mesprit has a cheery personality, I would have wrote down her floating around upside down or something related, or whichever fits her personality best.
Either way, I love your stories and your only getting better! c:
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobtheMorpher In reply to personqwer [2012-04-27 06:55:55 +0000 UTC]
Meh, I'm stuck betwen a rock and a hard place deciding if this was fair or unfair.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
PokeTFFAn [2015-04-20 00:30:02 +0000 UTC]
Lol
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
MrTherandomguy42 In reply to PokeTFFAn [2015-04-20 02:12:20 +0000 UTC]
Yeah I doubt I will get around to continuing this. I hope you liked it though.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
KirbyTardos [2014-10-16 21:16:55 +0000 UTC]
This is so awesome! But what about the sequels?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
MrTherandomguy42 In reply to KirbyTardos [2014-10-16 23:51:49 +0000 UTC]
On indefinite hiatus. I may get back continuing this eventually, but Change of Seasons is forever cancelled, hence why it is in my scraps.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
dan1234rui [2012-11-05 00:49:31 +0000 UTC]
cool story
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
HardHatShetland [2012-06-08 01:42:43 +0000 UTC]
This... was... AWESOME! And very heartwarming at times. You certainly made an effort putting emotion into this.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
MrTherandomguy42 In reply to HardHatShetland [2012-06-08 02:39:37 +0000 UTC]
Thank you for your feedback! I really appreciate it. I also have ideas for the Mesprit one but that will still be awhile off (need to get my medication first but before that I should at least do the first four letters of my upcoming A to Z Pokemon TFs).
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
pipluplover2003 [2012-05-25 17:57:48 +0000 UTC]
Hidden by Commenter
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Frozen-Doopliss [2012-05-13 02:14:58 +0000 UTC]
This was a pretty nice read overall; the TF was well described, and Andrew's backstory was interesting as well. On the downside, I think that you might've gone overboard on exposition in places, particularly on the description of the plot points in Platinum, since most of your audience would probably have at least a passing familiarity with them.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
RobtheMorpher [2012-04-26 23:19:44 +0000 UTC]
Finally, it's about time. Given how long it was though, and how good this story is, it was probably worth it to a lot of people while not worth it to a lot of others. You may have lost a watcher or two, I'm not sure. I for one think this is balanced by how long it took. Perhaps if the Mespirt and Uxie ones don't take as long as this one did to fully complete, you may get watchers back/gain more watchers. It all depends on how much dedication you put into it.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Erakir [2012-04-26 23:04:58 +0000 UTC]
I'm on my phone so can't really write much, but wow. Just wow. I enjoyed reading this more than I can express, really. Extremely well written, good depth, narration, all that stuff....but really, it was just a wonderful little story to read.
Also, Azelf is awesome :3
Amazing work, here.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
personqwer [2012-04-26 23:03:42 +0000 UTC]
Its glorious.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0