RiEile [2016-09-25 16:15:56 +0000 UTC]
Hello! I saw this work on ProjectComment and would like to share my thoughts.
I love the moderation that is evident in every aspect of this piece: colour, composition, detail. You've managed to create a stable, relaxed, working atmosphere. The viewer puts everything away, creates some distance between themselves and the world, focuses on abstract rather than on tangible things. The only entrance to the outside world is the fence on the right. It is beautifully rendered, but it ends exactly in the corner that should generally be avoided in terms of composition.
One technical moment I want to highlight is how grey of the mountain creeps on to the green grass and reverse - really cool effect! On the other hand the top of the closest mountain is a bit too uniform - maybe a bit of blue from the sky introduced subtly would make it more realistic, but I am afraid that making it more realistic would actually ruin the impact, it is a tradeoff I suppose.
Then I'd like to compliment the buildings and all the man-made stuff here, it looks really organic and a tiny human figure gives a feeling of the second presence in this contemplative scene. One thing that bothers me is that the house on the right and the huts (straw?) on the left are roughly on the same level and the same distance away from the viewer: it impairs the composition. The absence of the foreground is understandable, but then there should still be some hierarchy. As you have made some mountains further than the others, maybe the buildings also should not all stand in one horizontal line.
I suppose that all these tiny issues with composition arise from using a real life reference, and it is hard to know when to step away from it. But being aware of these things can help you create believable scenes with inspiration drawn from real life objects.
I had a look through your gallery and really loved the landscapes, do not give it up, they (together with this one) are very cool!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1