Comments: 8
SirNaelyan [2009-01-10 02:00:45 +0000 UTC]
Great rhythm, dude. I had a lot of fun reading this out loud and trying not to get too loud (dad's in bed...oops)-- there's definitely a big change in rhythm and intensity as the poem reaches its climax, and I bet it was really fun to hear you read this.
It implies a story without really telling one in a really linear way. Reading it feels sort of like fragmented imaginings. That goes well with the whole idea of seeing those burning crosses-- even if there is no story to tell, if you spent your night safe-- you'd know there was one out there.
There's something slightly sexual about a butterfly knife silently fluttering between this rib and that, and something just as carnal about hate dribbling out through spit. I really like that part of the poem just for its twisted sensuality.
"they burned crosses outside my school...dressed for halloween..." puts the narrator as a child for me, only that tone of the child is almost immediately abandoned, really, because the subject matter takes over and it's all about weaving a really terrible beast from a third person perspective. This change is a little confusing for me. It is not unsettling as if a child is forced to grow up too quickly, mind you-- more like, it doesn't quite do anything for the poem's content. It might possibly be more powerful if you picked one or the other.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
vix0r In reply to SirNaelyan [2009-01-13 23:34:18 +0000 UTC]
You, my friend, rock.
I agree with your point about the transition from child to... well, whatever. Adult, I guess. That problem stems mostly from the fact that the first is an anecdotal (and completely true) experience of mine, and the others are merely things that have happened in my town regarding the same problem of race relations.
Not sure how to fix it. I don't want to dump the beginning, but I'm not sure the rest of the poem would sound as good if I tried to lead it all from the voice of a child. Then again, maybe it would be okay. I could certainly keep the stuff about the butterfly knife and stuff.
Anyway, thanks once again for the comment. I always look forward to hearing what you have to say.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
SirNaelyan In reply to vix0r [2009-01-14 04:47:51 +0000 UTC]
Good that you like hearing what I'm going to say-- I think I like leaving in-depth comments enough to do it as much as possible because then I get more of the artists' perspective on their pieces, so it's kind of cool, yanno?
I understand about not wanting either of the voices to disappear from the poem. Maybe if you can think of some more anecdotes from childhood and intersperse them with the historical events, you could work with both at the same time. It might even become a poem you read as a duet with a young child, or just another person.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0