Comments: 17
The-Mirrorball-Man [2012-03-21 08:32:52 +0000 UTC]
This is marvelous, magnificent. Combined with the story, the image opens up a whole universe.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
bensen-daniel [2012-03-12 12:16:18 +0000 UTC]
Lovely creature, lovely description!
I get a good feel for the voice of this character.
The billboard is odd---perhaps this civilization has grown up after a horrendous bio-weapon apocalypse, and the odd-looking people he sees in the advertisement are modern-day H. sapiens, while he is something else?
Nice tension at the end there, and that's a kickass weapon.
Oh, my only critisism is that I'm not exactly sure about the geometry of things. He's in a cage dangling from a helicopter?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
whalewithlegs In reply to bensen-daniel [2012-03-12 12:55:36 +0000 UTC]
Thanks, very much! Teaching writing is making me think a lot more about how I approach writing myself. I really appreciate you pointing me toward those podcasts - they've been very useful, especially the one by James Morrow. I just finished teaching a segment about character, and next on to setting.
Oh yes, the billboard (in the dream, the people on the billboards were Asian and African, but I had never seen a non-Caucasian before. My colony consisted only of a relatively genetically non-diverse population) ... I tried to leave it sort of ambiguous, as if the narrator really didn't understand what he was seeing or that there were other types of people. He's supposed to be from some sort of post-apocalyptic re-colonization effort, after the culture that sent original colonies out crashed. Maybe he's from a world that was originally an Earth colony. But, I also to allow reader interpretation, so I don't know if it works! Hopefully the more intuitive interpretation you got still fits the story.
Thanks for the crit! I'll try to fix that.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
bensen-daniel In reply to whalewithlegs [2012-03-12 13:02:03 +0000 UTC]
ohh...I see. Hm. I think you'd need more explanation to make it clear that a technological person had never even seen a picture of a non-white before. (Maybe his part of the world is under a radio-opaque dome or something?) The fact that you use Coca-Cola makes me think this is earth.
It's an interesting question about reader interpretation. On the one hand, I like books that give me the space to make my own explanations for why things happen (usually it's movies more than books that do this). On the other hand, you don't want someone to misinterpret your story and discard it because they think they disagree with you. For example:
Writer: Bob flew above a beautiful rainforest.
Reader: People can't fly! This book is nonsense and I refuse to read it.
Of course, most readers give a little more benefit of the doubt, but there's still a danger that people won't understand what you think you wrote on the page. 👍: 0 ⏩: 1
whalewithlegs In reply to bensen-daniel [2012-03-12 13:16:52 +0000 UTC]
That's a good point .. hmmm ... the point about the Coke is something I had't thought of either. I'll probably leave it as it for now, but I were to keep on going I might have other characters make fun of the narrator for not knowing about other races. I try to give the impression that he's kind of a whiner that people don't really like that much, so it would work out in the end :3
👍: 0 ⏩: 1