Comments: 17
edelstrange [2010-07-14 19:33:13 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Ahh~ I suck at critiquing, but here goes.
First of all...I would say your coloring is pretty good. The shading on the dress is lovely.
But before you do any coloring at all, decide a light source. Is it from above, from the left...once you have, you will have no problem coloring. When I look at this picture, I would think it's coming from the left, hence the cat's shadow, but then on the girl's upper body it appears as if the light is from above. Same with the hair, and the face. Just work with light sources!
Of course, perspective is kind of annoying to work with, but also fun..the cat doesn't look like he's with the girl, or he's on the floor...maybe if you drew him from a more "above" look, like, not so much of his body is shown leaning to the right. Try all sorts of perspectives and you'll be mastering it in no time.
Critiques aside, this is a pretty good picture. I love her dress, and the floor design. It makes a nice birthday gift indeed e.deviantart.net/emoticons/s/s… " width="15" height="15" alt="" title=" (Smile)"/>
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Farewell-Spring [2010-04-27 00:06:28 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Critique request from #Traditional-Media :
Very beautiful composition, the girl is just lovely and coloring is very nice.
I think you did good with coloring, technique is nice however I think there’s an overall issue with the placement of shadows and lights, for example look at her left hand, colors on her glove are lighter around the corner of her fingers and go darker towards the middle of her hand, I don’t really get why that is this way because there’s not a light source coming from the floor therefore it should be the other way round, darker in the corners and lighter in the middle. You need to keep in mind from where exactly your light sources are coming when coloring your drawing.
Anatomy is pretty good; however she looks a little bit flat. Overall it needs darker tone to give the girl’s body a 3d effect.
Also perspective on the cat seems to be off compared to that of the girl, it seems on the girl as if the viewer is directly on top of her, however on the cat it looks like if the viewer is only in front of him a maybe a little bit up, but not the same as it is for the girl.
Overall this is nice piece, very good composition and I love the attention you put to all details. Keep up the nice work!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
katherinebaker [2010-07-24 19:01:29 +0000 UTC]
I am critiqueing on the second piece. I love this so much. It has an amazing 3d illusion to it which makes it sort of magical. The expression on her face is amazing; it speaks for help and anguish. Where as the cat looks so astounded. I just adore how you have made the image look so 3d as it is. The background of the squares adds to the effect also. The only thing i would say to improve on is that maybe you could do another one which is alice in wonderland themed. That would make it cooler. I don't really know if i agree with the hair colour. It seems a bit much. The shading is amazing i just wish she had a better expression on her face but overall 8/10!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Dusky-Dawn [2010-07-24 18:58:25 +0000 UTC]
I do like this story book feel to the style, even for anime. You have a creative choice in clothing design, really liking the detail in the dress. Her hair is very organically composed, it really helps move the eye around the piece. The movement of the hair leads the eye into the detail of the dress. The addition of the cat helps to keep from having dead spots in the piece where the viewer's eye doesn't get stuck.
The first problem my eye is drawn to is the arm laying on the floor: First, the the fore arm is too long. Your fore arm when you bend your elbow to meet your shoulder should roughly be the same length, maybe a tad longer, going from elbow to finger tips. Also the way you separate the glove from the skin is a little much, it looks like a thick rubber material.
Also your light source seems to be a little questionable judging from the shadows.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
WriteEscape [2010-07-24 18:27:47 +0000 UTC]
your colouring style is pefect, when i need an illistrater for my books i'll send you a note.
the pose is unique but i would've gone for a standing pose with maybe a bit of shaddow.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Charlene-Art [2010-07-16 14:01:40 +0000 UTC]
this is really nice! I love your colouring style, you use pencils wonderful. Nice bright consistent colour. Although personally I would have just made those tiles black - the grey gives it a faded look. The pose looks great - especially with the hand. I always have difficulty doing those types of poses. However, I'm not too sure what kind of pose you're aiming for - is she falling towards the floor or just lying on it. Looking at the perspecitve of the cat it kinda looks like she's falling towards it. But the shadow kind of gives the impression she's just on a flat surface. If she is falling, her hair should be kind of waving about her face and her body bending in an arch shape. also, if she's falling I would have her mouth open in shock, she looks quite calm as it is. As it is thought, it's a great piece, I do love the design of her dress.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Norash [2010-05-18 14:41:36 +0000 UTC]
das gute, wenn man nicht so supi englisch spricht ist, dass es mir egal ist, was sie zu deiner colo gesagt hat.xD ich find sie schön, schon seit jahren
und danke danke danke noch einmal für dieses supi süße bild, es hängt über meinem schreibtisch und alle leute, die in meine wohnugn kommen, fragen mich gleich, ob ich das gezeichnet hab. und denn sag ich immer: nein, das war meine beste freundin, mein schatzi, sie hat mir das zum B-Day geschenkt <3
und alle sind gleich neidisch xD die meisten finden den schlüssel ziemlich cool und die ganzen fließen und die Pose und überhaupt. xD
kuss mein schatz
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Yuleira In reply to Cut1efromb [2010-04-08 01:12:21 +0000 UTC]
It was X__x Hah! But you recognize it as a kitty so I succeed! xDD
Thank you! ^^
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Cut1efromb In reply to Yuleira [2010-04-08 03:03:48 +0000 UTC]
lol XDDD you're welcome!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0