HOME | DD

Description
UPDATE: added my redesigned Galeon to replace the Eevee-shadow-placeholder.

---------------

As usual... I felt like making a new overview image of my personal favorite new PKMN type idea: Wind.

It'd be nowhere near Fairy in terms of elegant execution this late in the franchise, but I feel like it's the coolest from the ones I can come up with, and the most fun one to think about in terms of retconning it onto existing PKMN.

The main reason for ever taking the idea of a wind type under serious consideration, appeared with the advent of generation 5, specifically the introduction of a Pokémon called Tornadus.
It immediately struck me as odd how Tornadus was part of a typical legendary trio, which often share a secondary type across the group, but differing in their primary type that shows their unique element within the trio.

So my question was, "why would Gamefreak make one member be a single-type, and then have that one type be the shared otherwise secondary type?".
Then I remembered some datamine from generation 4 times, where the typings of single type PKMN were listed twice in order to fill both type slots (for example LUXRAY ELECTRIC ELECTRIC).
This made me realize that Tornadus is actually a Flying type in both senses. Its primary type (and representing element) is Flying, and its secondary type is Flying. It's just that technically being Flying/Flying in practice makes it a pure Flying type.

Although that makes perfect sense ever since, and despite me often asking for more pure Flying PKMN, I feel that it would just look "right" in the context of its trio if Tornadus had a non-Flying primary type.
And that would certainly be the case if there was an actual wind-type, making it Wind/Flying

Most peoples reaction to the concept is: "Flying already covers the concept of wind"
And at first glance it very well does (moves like Hurricane, Tornadus...), but there is a lot of things that are wind-related but don't have anything to do with Flying-type (meaning the wind-concept is not exclusively covered by Flying.. similar to how sand isn't exclusively covered by only Ground or Rock), and of course the core concept of the Flying type is the act of defying gravity by skill, hence the 100% non-elemental name "Flying". Like Fighting or Poison, it's a specific skill-kind of type.

For it to be a good candidate for a new type, it has to do several things:

1. Plausible retcon potential
with 800+ pokemon in existence, there have to already be existing PKMN by now that would make sense to be changed into having the new type (just like there was 1 or two lines per generation that were easily retconned to be Fairy), with enough diversity to show off the different key aspects of the new type.

Of course this is a large part of what the picture is about. Here's some explanations on why certain PKMN are included:
-Pidgeot. It always struck me as the "special" one out of the regional birds, the one I wished had a bigger Sp.Atk and focus on wind-causing moves.. with Mega Pidgeot being a thing, it seems like Gamefreak thought so as well.
-Gyarados, because it honestly has nothing to do with actual flight, other than possibly resembling japanese windsock-balloons called koinobori (and inspiration doesn't necessarily have to express in a PKMNs type if that's all it is). This, coupled with its often mentioned tendencies to cause powerful storms make it a perfect candidate.
-Jumpluff and Drifblim are examples of Pokemon that aren't actually flying, but are easily affected by wind currents and are perfectly comfortable with it.
-Fan-Rotom: couldn't be more obvious, and it also solves the, due to Levitate, useless Ground immunity of its secondary type, while making it stick out among the other handful Electric/Flying types. Like all of its forms, this makes it look like a rare colorful elemental combination.
-Tornadus: main reason for even considering this seriously as stated earlier.
-Lugia: it's the Diving Pokemon and spends its life underwater, where there is essentially zero use of Flying.. honestly the only reason it even has the Flying type can only be due to a possible storm-theme, its signature move Aeroblast and to complement other legendary birds (although it resembles them the least), most of which can be used to argue for a Wind-type instead. If we are already retconning Lugia however, I'd take the opportunity to sneak in the Water type that everyone would consider as an obvious type it should have had all along. But I wouldn't make Water its primary element as a cliche opposite of Ho-ohs Fire, rather I would put the Water type secondary, to represent a contrast to Ho-ohs 100% deserved secondary Flying type.
-Aromatisse/Weezing/Vanilluxe/Butterfree etc. are all included because they rely on spreading something through the air to affect their opponent, whether it's aromatic scents, poisonous gasses, hazardous powder or freezing particles.
-Arcanine is featured mainly for its numerous speed-related references, but it's noteworthy that it is flat out called Windie in japanese
-Shiftry is based on Tengu the wind-demon, so it belongs into this group more than most candidates.
I did however have serious difficulty deciding what type to ditch. I figured that it wouldn't be the first time a PKMN with plant-related features would not itself be a Grass type (Florges, Comfey come to mind), and its prankster nature is more crucial to its concept... but there is still the fact that it evolves with a LEAF STONE that bothers me. Although I guess the whole idea of this type requires a retcon of big enough proportions, that switching out the Leaf Stone for some kind of Wind Stone would be no big deal whatsoever.

2. it needs to have potential for a handful of "generic" regular PKMN-lines that would be pure type to give a solid justification for its existence (just as generation 6 added Slurpuff, Aromatisse and Florges to make sure the Fairy type wasn't over 90% represented by secondary typed pokemon), so here are some vague ideas that I have considered but haven't gotten around turning into proper fakemon yet:
-a 3 stage cloud-based Pokemon (think, hybrid design of Castform/Tornadus with a purer and simpler "wind"-element feel to it)
-pseudo aquatic: aquatic creature-based pokemon that are light enough to substitute the liquid medium with air, swimming in the sky so to speak (imagine flying whale)
-continuous storm generating PKMN (think tornado with some kind of body in its core or base)
-a mystic mammal that runs around on clouds (think Landorus therians feet on a lightweight eeveelution)

3. potential for moves
as seen on the right-side of the image, there is already quite a pool to choose from... so big in fact, that it actually poses a problem, as lots of the moves are of diverse types already. A solution, or rather let's call it an interesting gimmick for the type, would be to make conflicting moves dual typed in the same fashion as Hawluchas move Flying-Press (dual types are a tremendously underused exciting mechanic that may be in need of some refining in order to be "unleashed", which could then cause fundamental changes in roles of quite some existing moves...anything mud-related being Water+Ground, Fighting+element for elemental punches/fangs/etc.)

4. it has to add something statistically unique to the type chart. In other words it shouldn't be a copy-paste of the Flying type with slight changes for example, but as you can see on the picture, I managed to give it extremely unique match-ups, while also attempting to balance the current type chart a bit (buffing Ice and other weaker types defensively, nerfing offensive powerhouses like Ground, Fairy and Fire etc.)

Clearly I've grown fond of the idea at this point... but I'm not expecting it to turn into an official type anytime soon ;O

--Addendum--

I figure I should back up the type match ups with at least some kind of flimsy reasoning so it doesn't seem completely random.

First part that had to be addressed is the interaction between Flying and Wind.
Flying types are masters of flight (duh), hence they can handle "rough weather" better than other types. (resisting Wind)

In contrast, simple Wind-types who are usually light-weight and easy to throw out of balance, are ironically susceptible to their own powers (but not so much that it'd be an actual weakness, this just explains why they aren't resisting themselves, as would normally be the case with ements of this kind). It's only when they combine with a type that resists Wind (Grass, Ground, Flying..) that they are really stable Wind-types (Tornadus for example).

So with Flying being the superior fighters in the air in terms of maneuvering, simple Wind types are easy target for them, it's like a Fighting PKMN beating up a Normal one on the ground. (Flying weakness)

However, being able to get tossed around easily makes them especially vulnerable to 2 additional types:

Dragon (who smack them around like plush toys with their sheer power and rage) and Psychic (lightweight creatures make for great telekinetic practice. Just look at Weezing, a floating gas bomb. If that's not something you'd imagine easily getting quadruple blown up by someone just thinking about it nearby, then I don't know what does)

That covers the weaknesses (note that they're still vulnerable to moves of most other types just like any others are.. weaknesses are about what types are not merely effective but super effective.)

What wind types actually resist however, are primarily types that modify the weather. Wind types are less prone to shifts in temperature and humidity than most other types.
That covers the resistances to all those convenient coverage elements of Water, Fire and Ice.

They also resist Ground for the same reason Bug does, being lightweight/agile. Those kind of moves just don't bother them as much as the average battler.

Onto Wind moves and their coverage.

Wind moves would usually focus on causing storms, using them as a means to turn other things into projectiles (hence the plethora of dual type moves from combining wind with different elements), or using the same power to build unexpected momentum on themselves, enabling them to execute direct hits faster than opponents can react. As with any types offensive side, it of course depends on the individual PKMN how they use the type for offense.

With that in mind..

In addition to Flying types, Wind moves are bad choices against heavy, firm, rooted types like Rock/Ground/Grass/Steel

On top of those, Dragons resist them as well, simply to fit with their gimmick of resisting all the basic elemental types of Water/Fire/Grass/Electric.

Wind moves do less damage to Ice types, as "harsh conditions" are essentially their lifestyle.

At this point Wind sounds like the worst type for coverage moves ever, so it's time to mention some strengths:

Fire normally feeds on oxygen, hence while "blowing it out" can be a really bad idea. But this is the freaking Wind type, so we're not talking about gentle stream of air, we're talking about abruptly separating the flame from the fuel to interrupt the process.

Feels like an obvious RPG element match-up to me, but if I have to pinpoint a reason, Lugia alone is enough. The real master of ocean currents now. It's not Water, it blows Water off the battlefield.

And since Wind is bad against Flying PKMN who are literally the masters of flight, it's at the same time great against their favourite prey, Bugs.

Ghost types, while not literal ghosts, are rather weird creatures which, once you get past the spooky image, have some things in common with wind types. They're not just often lightweight, but even made of gaseous material. Hence the same weakness reason to Wind as Wind itself.

Interestingly, this gives Wind moves a cool coverage spot that isn't present otherwise yet. Unlike Flying, which is great for dealing with a few more physical things, Wind is great for taking care of some basic elements (Water, Fire, Electric)

Description
UPDATE: added my redesigned Galeon to replace the Eevee-shadow-placeholder.

---------------

As usual... I felt like making a new overview image of my personal favorite new PKMN type idea: Wind.

It'd be nowhere near Fairy in terms of elegant execution this late in the franchise, but I feel like it's the coolest from the ones I can come up with, and the most fun one to think about in terms of retconning it onto existing PKMN.

The main reason for ever taking the idea of a wind type under serious consideration, appeared with the advent of generation 5, specifically the introduction of a Pokémon called Tornadus.
It immediately struck me as odd how Tornadus was part of a typical legendary trio, which often share a secondary type across the group, but differing in their primary type that shows their unique element within the trio.

So my question was, "why would Gamefreak make one member be a single-type, and then have that one type be the shared otherwise secondary type?".
Then I remembered some datamine from generation 4 times, where the typings of single type PKMN were listed twice in order to fill both type slots (for example LUXRAY ELECTRIC ELECTRIC).
This made me realize that Tornadus is actually a Flying type in both senses. Its primary type (and representing element) is Flying, and its secondary type is Flying. It's just that technically being Flying/Flying in practice makes it a pure Flying type.

Although that makes perfect sense ever since, and despite me often asking for more pure Flying PKMN, I feel that it would just look "right" in the context of its trio if Tornadus had a non-Flying primary type.
And that would certainly be the case if there was an actual wind-type, making it Wind/Flying

Most peoples reaction to the concept is: "Flying already covers the concept of wind"
And at first glance it very well does (moves like Hurricane, Tornadus...), but there is a lot of things that are wind-related but don't have anything to do with Flying-type (meaning the wind-concept is not exclusively covered by Flying.. similar to how sand isn't exclusively covered by only Ground or Rock), and of course the core concept of the Flying type is the act of defying gravity by skill, hence the 100% non-elemental name "Flying". Like Fighting or Poison, it's a specific skill-kind of type.

For it to be a good candidate for a new type, it has to do several things:

1. Plausible retcon potential
with 800+ pokemon in existence, there have to already be existing PKMN by now that would make sense to be changed into having the new type (just like there was 1 or two lines per generation that were easily retconned to be Fairy), with enough diversity to show off the different key aspects of the new type.

Of course this is a large part of what the picture is about. Here's some explanations on why certain PKMN are included:
-Pidgeot. It always struck me as the "special" one out of the regional birds, the one I wished had a bigger Sp.Atk and focus on wind-causing moves.. with Mega Pidgeot being a thing, it seems like Gamefreak thought so as well.
-Gyarados, because it honestly has nothing to do with actual flight, other than possibly resembling japanese windsock-balloons called koinobori (and inspiration doesn't necessarily have to express in a PKMNs type if that's all it is). This, coupled with its often mentioned tendencies to cause powerful storms make it a perfect candidate.
-Jumpluff and Drifblim are examples of Pokemon that aren't actually flying, but are easily affected by wind currents and are perfectly comfortable with it.
-Fan-Rotom: couldn't be more obvious, and it also solves the, due to Levitate, useless Ground immunity of its secondary type, while making it stick out among the other handful Electric/Flying types. Like all of its forms, this makes it look like a rare colorful elemental combination.
-Tornadus: main reason for even considering this seriously as stated earlier.
-Lugia: it's the Diving Pokemon and spends its life underwater, where there is essentially zero use of Flying.. honestly the only reason it even has the Flying type can only be due to a possible storm-theme, its signature move Aeroblast and to complement other legendary birds (although it resembles them the least), most of which can be used to argue for a Wind-type instead. If we are already retconning Lugia however, I'd take the opportunity to sneak in the Water type that everyone would consider as an obvious type it should have had all along. But I wouldn't make Water its primary element as a cliche opposite of Ho-ohs Fire, rather I would put the Water type secondary, to represent a contrast to Ho-ohs 100% deserved secondary Flying type.
-Aromatisse/Weezing/Vanilluxe/Butterfree etc. are all included because they rely on spreading something through the air to affect their opponent, whether it's aromatic scents, poisonous gasses, hazardous powder or freezing particles.
-Arcanine is featured mainly for its numerous speed-related references, but it's noteworthy that it is flat out called Windie in japanese
-Shiftry is based on Tengu the wind-demon, so it belongs into this group more than most candidates.
I did however have serious difficulty deciding what type to ditch. I figured that it wouldn't be the first time a PKMN with plant-related features would not itself be a Grass type (Florges, Comfey come to mind), and its prankster nature is more crucial to its concept... but there is still the fact that it evolves with a LEAF STONE that bothers me. Although I guess the whole idea of this type requires a retcon of big enough proportions, that switching out the Leaf Stone for some kind of Wind Stone would be no big deal whatsoever.

2. it needs to have potential for a handful of "generic" regular PKMN-lines that would be pure type to give a solid justification for its existence (just as generation 6 added Slurpuff, Aromatisse and Florges to make sure the Fairy type wasn't over 90% represented by secondary typed pokemon), so here are some vague ideas that I have considered but haven't gotten around turning into proper fakemon yet:
-a 3 stage cloud-based Pokemon (think, hybrid design of Castform/Tornadus with a purer and simpler "wind"-element feel to it)
-pseudo aquatic: aquatic creature-based pokemon that are light enough to substitute the liquid medium with air, swimming in the sky so to speak (imagine flying whale)
-continuous storm generating PKMN (think tornado with some kind of body in its core or base)
-a mystic mammal that runs around on clouds (think Landorus therians feet on a lightweight eeveelution)

3. potential for moves
as seen on the right-side of the image, there is already quite a pool to choose from... so big in fact, that it actually poses a problem, as lots of the moves are of diverse types already. A solution, or rather let's call it an interesting gimmick for the type, would be to make conflicting moves dual typed in the same fashion as Hawluchas move Flying-Press (dual types are a tremendously underused exciting mechanic that may be in need of some refining in order to be "unleashed", which could then cause fundamental changes in roles of quite some existing moves...anything mud-related being Water+Ground, Fighting+element for elemental punches/fangs/etc.)

4. it has to add something statistically unique to the type chart. In other words it shouldn't be a copy-paste of the Flying type with slight changes for example, but as you can see on the picture, I managed to give it extremely unique match-ups, while also attempting to balance the current type chart a bit (buffing Ice and other weaker types defensively, nerfing offensive powerhouses like Ground, Fairy and Fire etc.)

Clearly I've grown fond of the idea at this point... but I'm not expecting it to turn into an official type anytime soon ;O

--Addendum--

I figure I should back up the type match ups with at least some kind of flimsy reasoning so it doesn't seem completely random.

First part that had to be addressed is the interaction between Flying and Wind.
Flying types are masters of flight (duh), hence they can handle "rough weather" better than other types. (resisting Wind)

In contrast, simple Wind-types who are usually light-weight and easy to throw out of balance, are ironically susceptible to their own powers (but not so much that it'd be an actual weakness, this just explains why they aren't resisting themselves, as would normally be the case with ements of this kind). It's only when they combine with a type that resists Wind (Grass, Ground, Flying..) that they are really stable Wind-types (Tornadus for example).

So with Flying being the superior fighters in the air in terms of maneuvering, simple Wind types are easy target for them, it's like a Fighting PKMN beating up a Normal one on the ground. (Flying weakness)

However, being able to get tossed around easily makes them especially vulnerable to 2 additional types:

Dragon (who smack them around like plush toys with their sheer power and rage) and Psychic (lightweight creatures make for great telekinetic practice. Just look at Weezing, a floating gas bomb. If that's not something you'd imagine easily getting quadruple blown up by someone just thinking about it nearby, then I don't know what does)

That covers the weaknesses (note that they're still vulnerable to moves of most other types just like any others are.. weaknesses are about what types are not merely effective but super effective.)

What wind types actually resist however, are primarily types that modify the weather. Wind types are less prone to shifts in temperature and humidity than most other types.
That covers the resistances to all those convenient coverage elements of Water, Fire and Ice.

They also resist Ground for the same reason Bug does, being lightweight/agile. Those kind of moves just don't bother them as much as the average battler.

Onto Wind moves and their coverage.

Wind moves would usually focus on causing storms, using them as a means to turn other things into projectiles (hence the plethora of dual type moves from combining wind with different elements), or using the same power to build unexpected momentum on themselves, enabling them to execute direct hits faster than opponents can react. As with any types offensive side, it of course depends on the individual PKMN how they use the type for offense.

With that in mind..

In addition to Flying types, Wind moves are bad choices against heavy, firm, rooted types like Rock/Ground/Grass/Steel

On top of those, Dragons resist them as well, simply to fit with their gimmick of resisting all the basic elemental types of Water/Fire/Grass/Electric.

Wind moves do less damage to Ice types, as "harsh conditions" are essentially their lifestyle.

At this point Wind sounds like the worst type for coverage moves ever, so it's time to mention some strengths:

Fire normally feeds on oxygen, hence while "blowing it out" can be a really bad idea. But this is the freaking Wind type, so we're not talking about gentle stream of air, we're talking about abruptly separating the flame from the fuel to interrupt the process.

Feels like an obvious RPG element match-up to me, but if I have to pinpoint a reason, Lugia alone is enough. The real master of ocean currents now. It's not Water, it blows Water off the battlefield.

And since Wind is bad against Flying PKMN who are literally the masters of flight, it's at the same time great against their favourite prey, Bugs.

Ghost types, while not literal ghosts, are rather weird creatures which, once you get past the spooky image, have some things in common with wind types. They're not just often lightweight, but even made of gaseous material. Hence the same weakness reason to Wind as Wind itself.

Interestingly, this gives Wind moves a cool coverage spot that isn't present otherwise yet. Unlike Flying, which is great for dealing with a few more physical things, Wind is great for taking care of some basic elements (Water, Fire, Electric)