HOME | DD

Nayzak — April fools day... for Muslims?

Published: 2013-04-02 16:48:28 +0000 UTC; Views: 29743; Favourites: 179; Downloads: 273
Redirect to original
Description Assalaamu alaikum [peace be to you],

Why comments are disabled? read EDIT 2 (at the bottom)


Aprils Fool’s Day, known for “All Fools’ Day”, is celebrated annually in the beginning of each April, where people anticipate playing practical jokes and hoaxes on each other. It is an odd celebration with a strange and uncertain history.
April Fools' Day is observed throughout the Western world. Practices include sending someone on a "fool's errand," looking for things that don't exist; playing pranks, and trying to get people to believe ridiculous things.


Origins
Once upon a time, back in 16th-century France, before computers, people celebrated New Year's Day on March 25, the advent of spring. It was a festive time. They partied steadily until April 1. In 1564, when the calendar reformed and became Gregorian, under the influence of Pope Gregory, King Charles IX proclaimed, perhaps pompously, that New Year's Day should be celebrated on January 1st instead of in the spring. Diehard conservatives resisted the change (or perhaps didn't hear about it due to the absence of e-mail) and continued to celebrate New Year's from March 25 to April 1. During this period of spring festivity, the more flexible French mocked the rigid revelers by sending them foolish gifts and invitations to nonexistent parties. The victim of an April Fools' Day prank was called a "Poisson d 'Avril," or an "April Fish," because at that time of year, the sun was leaving the zodiacal sign of Pisces.
April Fools' Day hit its stride (avoiding the banana peel) in England in the 18th century, and was brought to colonial America by the English, Scottish, and French.
French children sometimes tape a picture of a fish on the back of their schoolmates, crying "Poisson d'Avril" when the prank is discovered. In Scotland it’s known for “Gowkie Day”, and the following day, victims are pinned on their backs signs reading “kick me”.


Misfortunes of “Prankism”
It is quite evident that a lot of peoples from different cultures, Islamic or non-Islamic, do enjoy celebrating this day, especially the funkiest ones.
It is indeed important to spread laughter and lightness; however, it should not grow in a soil full of warms of “lies” and “fabrication”, which will definitely cause negative results.

It is quite important to know that even though the intention behind this action is sound and deeply desirable, it is still considered as sprouting from a “mixed”, unclear and grey intention that has the desire to mislead.
“Prankism” is part and parcel of laughter, and we love watching some pompous person get taken down a peg or two in a humorous fashion. But in real life, a practical joke, when played with cruel and malicious intent by cruel and malicious people, has a very high chance of going horribly wrong.

These are examples of some April Fools pranks that went very wrong:

a- In one tragic April Fools' case, an employer reportedly thought it would be funny to shoot a worker with a high-powered hose, resulting in serious bodily injury to the worker. A separate April Fools' incident was investigated as second-degree assault after someone spread superglue on a toilet at Wal-Mart, resulting in injuries to an unsuspecting patron.

b- Randy Wood pranked his ex-wife in 2004 by asking her to come over so he could show her something.
When she arrived at his house, Woods appeared to be hanging from a tree in his front yard (he was actually being held by a safety harness).
His unknowing ex-wife dialed 911 before he could reveal the gag. Wood was fined $1,000 and jailed for a year.

c- Two teenagers decided it would be funny to cover a stop sign in plastic wrap. They even bragged about it on their Facebook page.
Then at 4 in the afternoon on a road in Circleville, Ohio, an 80-year-old woman named Jeanne Shea drove through the intersection without stopping. Another car smashed into her. The passenger, her 85-year-old sister Mary Spangler, was killed, and Ms. Shea may have to have her leg amputated.
The young men, Derek W. Greenlee, 18, and Seth R. Stonerock, 19, were found after people read their Facebook posts and reported them to the police. They were charged with manslaughter.
* source: Internet

What does Islam say about April Fools Day?
Telling lies is bad conduct. It is not proper for righteous people and true Muslims; rather, it is a sign of hypocrisy, as the Prophet -peace be upon him- said, “The hypocrite has three characteristics: he tells lies, breaks his promise, and breaches the trust”. the Prophet -peace be upon him- warned against lying for the purpose of entertaining people. He said, “Woe on anyone who speaks to entertain the people by lying, woe on him, woe on him…”
Several Prophetic hadiths warned the Muslims against frightening others seriously or jokingly.

Consequently, lying is forbidden in any form, and on this occasion (April Fools’ Day) it is forbidden for four reasons:
1. The prohibition of lying which is confirmed by the Qur’an and the Sunnah,
2. The unwarranted grief or fear it may bring on a person or his entire family, even if only for one hour,
3. The betrayal of trust it entails,
4. The emulation of a silly custom that is not ours, that of lying.
Sometimes the idea of telling a lie on this day may be obnoxious to the whole society, not only to a person.

Based on Islamic teachings and the opinions of the scholars, true Muslims shouldn't lie, make pranks to laugh at people or put people in embarrassing situations. therefore, Muslims should avoid participate in anything related to April Fools Day.


It is agreed upon by all religions and sound minds that truthfulness is a virtue and lying is a vice. To tell the truth, your words should reflect reality; to tell a lie is to contradict what you are actually saying or doing. The worst kind of lying in sayings is perjury and in deeds it is hypocrisy.


from: [link] , [link] and [link]

I hope this was beneficial.


EDIT 1:
Some people seemed to dislike the serious expression on the boy's face. so I made him smiling.

EDIT 2:
Several commentors seemed upset because I am talking about a side of Islam which rejects their customs and beliefs. they appear to only want me to talk about what pleases them and when I talk about differences between Islam and their beliefs, they call me aggressor. in spite of all the happy and cheerful drawings in my gallery, these people say that all my latest drawings are angry and spread negativity.
In my articles and artworks, I present Islam the way I learned it. I present similarities between Islam and other beliefs and I also present differences. If a non-Muslim has the right to voice his opinion by pointing out an Islamic custom and disagreeing with it, then I, as a Muslim, have the same right to voice my opinion by pointing out a non-Islamic custom and disagreeing with it. I'm not attacking people's customs, I am merely presenting Islamic point of view so that people learn and benefit. I am not telling people what they should do or what they shouldn't. I am merely telling people what Islam teach Muslims to do and what it teaches them to avoid.
Therefore, I'm not interested to hear such nonsensical critiques. I'm blocking comments here because they became ridiculously annoying.


If I'm right, it's from the God Almighty. If I'm wrong, it's from myself.
Related content
Comments: 87

Nayzak In reply to ??? [2013-04-03 01:20:26 +0000 UTC]

I draw whatever I want.

and the girls I drew were not wearing Burqa.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

LightAnimaux [2013-04-03 00:58:11 +0000 UTC]

Yay, more people who don't like April Fools day!
It's a really annoying "holiday". I wish everyone would just stop celebrating it. :I

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to LightAnimaux [2013-04-03 01:03:39 +0000 UTC]

Well, we can't force people not to celebrate it if they wish to celebrate it. all we do is voice our disagreement. and let people know it.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

BlazeX-HD [2013-04-03 00:07:37 +0000 UTC]

I have a question:
What if I participated in this occasion purely for fun? I don't mean going on and lying to people, or doing the bad things that the other people that you mentioned did. I mean just saying something as if you're serious and then a few seconds later, you tell your friend that it was just a joke. Then we just have a good laugh about it. Would this be considered betraying what the Prophet -peace be upon him- said?

👍: 0 ⏩: 2

Nayzak In reply to BlazeX-HD [2013-04-03 00:20:35 +0000 UTC]

I don't think that making jokes for fun is something bad. as long as the jokes are not harmful, don't imply lying and don't embarrass and put people to shame. and as long as it's not done with exaggeration.
but there is something we need to keep in mind, we Muslim shouldn't imitate non-Muslims. therefore, if non-Muslims celebrate something un-Islamic in a certain day, we Muslims should avoid doing anything that may be seen as if we are participating in such celebrations with them.
If you always joke with your friends in an unharmful manner, then there is nothing wrong. if you do it on April Fools as an April Fools thing, then I believe it may not be the right thing to do. since it is considered imitation of non-Muslims. and the God knows best.
you can ask an Imam for a better answer.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

BlazeX-HD In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-03 00:27:51 +0000 UTC]

Alright, thank you! ^-^

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

BlazeX-HD In reply to BlazeX-HD [2013-04-03 00:13:26 +0000 UTC]

What I'm trying to say is that I tease my friends sometimes about things, but I don't go to the point where it harms someone. That's all.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Alceon112 [2013-04-02 22:58:08 +0000 UTC]

Hmmm...how about white lies?? You know the term "white lies" right??

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Timishayd [2013-04-02 22:45:54 +0000 UTC]

Very educational like always.
I personally don't like April's Fool (here in Mexico and other hispanic countries the celebration is in December 28th and it's called "Día de los Santos Inocentes").
Sometimes even the most seemingly innocent joke can seriously harm people.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to Timishayd [2013-04-02 23:39:53 +0000 UTC]

because when you plan to make the joke, you don't know the consequences yet. they may go overboard and it becomes harmful.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Timishayd In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-03 00:12:23 +0000 UTC]

That's right

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

crazy-aika [2013-04-02 22:34:37 +0000 UTC]

For me is ok, if the religion says to not lie, then its ok to not celebrate it, i have no problem. But really, those pranks are just evil, is not necessary to take it to that level.

Also thanks for telling us the story of april fools, i though it was related to the 28/Dec, because that day (at least in my country, i'm not sure of the other ones) is for pranks, called the Day of innocents/naives [Día de los inocentes] and i really have no idea how because of the king who looked for Jesus when he was a baby and then killed all the babies became a day of pranks.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

SlimStephen [2013-04-02 22:20:05 +0000 UTC]

You seem all ways angry about something.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to SlimStephen [2013-04-02 22:30:48 +0000 UTC]

it's not angry... it's serious.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SlimStephen In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-02 22:40:24 +0000 UTC]

There is fooling someone like a jump scary, and there being cruel. Like did you fool anyone for the lols before? I haven't because I am not that smart. Also, I didn't really care about April fools day because it the same day i put my dad six feet under.

You are a day late my friend.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to SlimStephen [2013-04-02 23:33:12 +0000 UTC]

I did fool my teacher when I was in school... but in that time, I didn't know that April fools was not allowed in Islam.

I know I'm a day late. this article and drawing are for April Fools of 2014. lol

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SlimStephen In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-02 23:38:31 +0000 UTC]

I kind of hate April 1 myself.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

ArantxaCosplayer [2013-04-02 21:55:22 +0000 UTC]

I forgot. The Spain's April Fool's Day is very special. Want to know why? Many countries used this day to do many jokes to famous people to entertain people but actually the real goal is to raise money for organizations that help children with disabilities. Is that perhaps a kind of sin, according to you? Are we bad people to consider a special day the perfect time to draw attention and help other people who need it? If you do not believe me look for a TV show in Spain called "Inocente, Inocente". Find out it and see it. No point in doing a review if you just want to see the bad side.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to ArantxaCosplayer [2013-04-02 22:32:33 +0000 UTC]

why do you ask a question and then answer it by yourself?

do you want my answer or you are just not interested to hear it?

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

ArantxaCosplayer [2013-04-02 21:45:16 +0000 UTC]

[...] true Muslims don't participate in anything related to April Fools Day[...]

I have a simple question... Is there any day you like, according to you?
Who are you to say if a person is a true Muslim? Are you the prophet perhaps? I think your radical views go too excessive. Many people who share your religious beliefs may be offended.

I think you take your religion too seriously and all you do is attack special days.

👍: 0 ⏩: 2

Nayzak In reply to ArantxaCosplayer [2013-04-02 22:29:29 +0000 UTC]

"I have a simple question... Is there any day you like, according to you?"
As a Muslim, I have 2 festivals, Eid-ul-Ad'ha and Eid-ul-fitr. they are the celebrations prescribed by our religion. we don't have the habit to add or remove from our religion. that's why Islam remained preserved this long.

"Who are you to say if a person is a true Muslim?"
I am not in position to judge. I never said so-and-so is a true Muslim and so-and-so is not a true Muslim. What I did is to present, based on Islamic teachings, what a true Muslim should/shouldn't do. of course this is not my own invention. anybody who reads about Islam and Islamic teachings will be able to have an idea of what a true Muslim is supposed to do and what he is not supposed to do.
If you saw me pointing my finger to somebody saying he's (or he's not) a true Muslim, then you'll have the right to ask "Who are you to say if a person is a true Muslim?"

"Are you the prophet perhaps?"
Nope. I never claimed to receive divine revelation. I never claimed God spoke to me. I never claimed to make prophecies. I am merely a seeker of knowledge who shares what he learns. nothing more, nothing less.
You need to check the definition of the word 'prophet' before you throw it at people.

"I think your radical views go too excessive."
My views are not radical. in modern time, when many people went secular, striving to follow the religious fundamentals is seen as radical by seculars. it's a matter of perspective.
besides, I'm not forcing my views on people. I'm only sharing them in my little page here. I'm not even inviting people to read them.

"Many people who share your religious beliefs may be offended."
if the reason why these people are offended is because I'm saying something wrong, then I'll be more than ready to listen to the truth and see stronger proof from them. and if it's proven to me that I'm wrong, I will be more than willing to take this article down and replace it with an apology.
while if the reason these people are offended is only because what I say is not to their liking, then this is the last thing I care about. I don't aim to please people. I aim to inform people what I believe to be the truth, even if it's what they dislike.

"I think you take your religion too seriously and all you do is attack special days."
I don't think that taking my religion seriously is something to be blamed for. my religion is my own business, whether I take it seriously or not is no one else's business. so I don't accept complains in this point.

As for your claim that I am attacking special days, I say this is a baseless claim. did you see me saying "stop celebrating Christmas/Valentine/April Fools" or "nobody should celebrate these days"?
I didn't say that. all I did is explain Islamic opinion on these days for people to learn and understand. I also explained why a Muslim doesn't celebrate these days. this is my freedom. I have the right to state my opinion or my religious opinion. and people have the right to know Islamic opinion on these matters. whether they agree with it or not.
My opinions here are not causing harm to anybody.
If my religious opinion is against a certain issue, then It's really dishonest from my part to compromise and hide it in order to please people. I took it upon myself to present the truth I believe as it is. of course I realize that some people may like it and some may dislike it. that's totally normal and I respect all people's opinions.

I hope I answered your question.

Peace

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic In reply to ArantxaCosplayer [2013-04-02 22:04:18 +0000 UTC]

^Agreed :\
Lately all of the devaitions (like others before me have commented) are getting...agressive?
"Therefore, true Muslims don't participate in anything related to April Fools Day."
I agree that April Fools Day can be harmful...but really? These unnecessary comments are being thrown into the body of the deviation's paragraphs! I remember a saying that my mom (who doesn't follow the saying anymore) that "Don't judge others" what the heck happened to that?

👍: 0 ⏩: 3

Nayzak In reply to Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic [2013-04-02 22:59:58 +0000 UTC]

Lately all of the devaitions (like others before me have commented) are getting...agressive?
It's easy to make allegations and accuse people. and it's much easier to debunk them.
you say ALL of my latest deviatuons are getting aggressive.
here are my latest ones with anime style drawings:
[link]
[link]
[link]
[link]
[link]
[link]
[link]
...
seriously! Do you see these aggressive? or you only see the ones you consider aggressive and ignore the rest?
Every time I draw a serious face, some people start complaining saying he's being aggressive. Every time I state a point of disagreement between Islam and other faiths/nations, people accuse me of being aggressive. Do I have to only state similarities and ignore differences so that I won't be called aggressive? Do I have to compromise my religion and just say what pleases people so that I won't be called aggressive?
but then, would I be honest and truthful if I did so?

you say:
"Therefore, true Muslims don't participate in anything related to April Fools Day."
I agree that April Fools Day can be harmful...but really? These unnecessary comments are being thrown into the body of the deviation's paragraphs! I remember a saying that my mom (who doesn't follow the saying anymore) that "Don't judge others" what the heck happened to that?

What's aggressive in stating that true Muslims don't do harmful things?
What's aggressive in stating that true Muslims don't lie?
What's aggressive in stating that true Muslims don't make fun of people?
What's aggressive in stating that true Muslims don't make stupid pranks on people?
Then next if I were to say "true Muslims don't drink alcohol and don't eat pork" or "true Muslims don't gamble" someone may come here and say I'm making aggressive comments.
I'm not judging X or Y or Z. My friend, I'm only stating what a true Muslim should/shouldn't do based on what Islam teaches. I didn't point fingers at people and calling them bad Muslims or true Muslims. did I?
but I can say, based on Islamic teachings, what a true Muslim should/shouldn't do. anybody reading religious books can know what a true follower of that religion should/shouldn't do.

You started your comment with a false accusation (claiming that ALL -I repeat: ALL- my latest work is getting aggressive. ALL means EVERYTHING). you didn't write that comment to me personally (you wrote it to somebody else) I feel I'm being slandered in my own page. If you wrote your comment to me, I would have the chance to reply. if I didn't come to read the comments here by chance, I wouldn't have read your comment here and replied. T____T

My friend, In fact, what you call 'aggressive' here, I call 'serious and firm stance' and 'no compromise'. it's just that we have different perspectives and different opinions.

I hope this makes things clear.
peace

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-02 23:27:44 +0000 UTC]

The deviations on holidays T.T
The other ones were fine, it's just that the holiday ones are giving a strange vibe, and you seem...angry?
There's nothing wrong with the Women drawings, they all look friendly and cute and the tone in your writing isn't...showing well anger...?

👍: 0 ⏩: 2

Iiwi In reply to Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic [2013-04-02 23:40:51 +0000 UTC]

I agree -x- His other works are fine, but it seems like nowadays in regards to the holidays he seems angry and showing anger.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to Iiwi [2013-04-02 23:53:44 +0000 UTC]

I'm not angry. I'm serious. I already explained to you.

the way I see it is that you are spamming my page.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Iiwi In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-03 00:00:31 +0000 UTC]

OXO I'm not spamming your page?

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to Iiwi [2013-04-03 00:14:11 +0000 UTC]

then if you have anything you don't like, please write a comment directly to me.

thanks

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Iiwi In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-03 00:26:45 +0000 UTC]

Er Okay.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Nayzak In reply to Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic [2013-04-02 23:38:30 +0000 UTC]

What you call 'anger' is just call 'serious tone'.
I am not promoting any aggression or negativity.
I consider myself a tolerant person and believe all people have the right to live and practice their faiths peacefully without any compulsion. and these articles about holidays don't contradict that. My understanding of tolerance doesn't imply 'mixing all different customs of the different religions into one melting pot'. I believe tolerance is that you respect what others do even if you disagree with it and reject it for yourself.
that's exactly what I'm doing. we Muslims reject these practices. but we respect that others have the right to practice them. we don't force our opinion on others. but we have the right to voice our opinion. It's only to allow people to know us and understand us.

as for the tone of the article, I believe it all depends on the subject, I also didn't have happy faces and happy tone when I discussed terrorism, honor killing, forced marriage and other such issues. when the topic requires happy face, I draw happy face. when the topic is serious, I try to draw serious face. that's all.
If you take any 10 random consecutive drawings of mine, you'll fine most of them are happy faces and the articles are with a happy tone.

peace

👍: 0 ⏩: 2

Iiwi In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-02 23:45:49 +0000 UTC]

Well of course not, why would you have a happy tone when talking about Terrorism that doesn't make sense oxo;

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-02 23:41:29 +0000 UTC]

Well hope to see more happy faces, this time not of more Muslim Women, I hope to see more interfaith drawings (I miss those...)

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

ArantxaCosplayer In reply to Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic [2013-04-02 22:24:36 +0000 UTC]

People of today (especially the most radical) not know how to accept the thoughts of today and do not want to accept that the world evolves, society evolves, humans evolved and with them the religion, thought, culture evolves. But do not accept it, they attack it. The first (no offense) not to accept this are the religious extremists (whether of religion that is). They want the world to follow the old traditions of a religion serious. What would the world be if we did? Probably we would live in constant ignorance

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to ArantxaCosplayer [2013-04-02 23:09:27 +0000 UTC]

People of today (especially the most radical) not know how to accept the thoughts of today and do not want to accept that the world evolves, society evolves, humans evolved and with them the religion
a perfect divine religion that evolves by adapting man-made innovations is a corrupted religion.
We believe that a divine religion doesn't need man-made evolution. it's supposed to be perfect and no additions are necessary. of course, there are certain flexible aspects of the religion where adaptations may be allowed. but in general, the subject of introducing new innovations to the religion is something we take very seriously.

But do not accept it, they attack it.
When a non-Muslim states his disagreement about Islamic customs, it's called freedom of speech.
When a Muslim states his disagreement about non-Islamic customs, it's called attack.
talk about double standard.

Nowhere did I say "nobody should celebrate what they want". nowhere did I say "people should be forced to follow the Islamic opinion". All I did was to explain what Islam says about these celebrations and why we Muslims don't celebrate them.
If you consider you have the right to reject some Islamic customs and voice your opinion, then you shouldn't deny us the same right to reject some of your customs and voice our opinions.

Peace

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic In reply to Pocky-Japan-Ai-epic [2013-04-02 22:06:36 +0000 UTC]

Oh and Nayzak I would appreciate if you made a deviation on other things such as exercise, a lot of Sheikhs (so and sos that nobody knew that they existed) are making fatwas against yoga even though our prayer poses come from yoga poses O_o

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

LadyNanako [2013-04-02 20:59:01 +0000 UTC]

I Don't Care About April Fools Day (I'm Kind Of A Tight Ass) But As Long As Your Not Being Stupid With Your Prank Then I Got Not Problem With It. That's The Only Reason The Day Can Turn Bad-People Being Stupid Like The Guys In Jack Ass.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

DaniRouge [2013-04-02 20:22:47 +0000 UTC]

Ok, now I am starting to feel that everything is wrong :/ Am I supposed to live in a cave or something? I`m happy I have a mind of my own...

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to DaniRouge [2013-04-02 21:04:09 +0000 UTC]

"Ok, now I am starting to feel that everything is wrong"
Of course not everything is wrong. only harmful things are wrong. and that's justifiable.

"Am I supposed to live in a cave or something?"
your personal habitat choice is unrelated to the article above.

"I`m happy I have a mind of my own..."
You're not alone there. Everybody has a mind of their own.
Deciding to follow beneficial and convincing religious rules doesn't mean we lack mind. it only means we are using our mind 'in the right way'.

Peace

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

SleepingNinniku [2013-04-02 19:58:11 +0000 UTC]

So Muslims don't tell jokes or watch movies or read fiction because it's made up stuff ergo lying? Or where exactly do you draw the line?

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to SleepingNinniku [2013-04-02 21:00:06 +0000 UTC]

No, of course we joke. but we prefer jokes that don't imply lying and making fun of people.
We may watch movies. but we prefer movies that do not propagate lies, falsehood, bad morals and corruption.
there is a saying by prophet Mohammed -peace be upon him- "do not harm nor reciprocate harm". which may mean that we should not do something that harms others, nor should we do something that harms us. entertainment is fine. sports are fine. having fun is fine. but only as long as it doesn't result in bad consequences. of course the line is to be drawn according to the situation. we can't make a set rule for everything, but I believe the above hadith can give us an idea.

I hope this answers your question.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Amikazi In reply to Nayzak [2013-04-02 21:39:25 +0000 UTC]

There are hadiths of the Prophet Muhammad joking but never lying. We watch movies, read books but one must remember it is always the content of these stories or jokes that depend on whether they are allowed or not.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to Amikazi [2013-04-02 21:46:31 +0000 UTC]

exactly.

some people think in extreme ways. when we say we don't make April Fools pranks, they think we never joke and we are always serious. as if all jokes imply lying and making pranks on people.

When we say we don't watch bad movies, some people may think we don't watch anything...

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

NinSega [2013-04-02 19:31:47 +0000 UTC]

Heh, I already knew without research that April Fool Day is non-islamic.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Miss-Jennifer-Lynn [2013-04-02 18:56:11 +0000 UTC]

Can you still prank people? Like, putting a whoopee cushion under a seat or something?

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to Miss-Jennifer-Lynn [2013-04-02 21:10:28 +0000 UTC]

if the prank would harms people physically or emotionally or puts them in an embarrassing or shameful situation, then I believe I prefer to avoid it.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

rui-thinik [2013-04-02 18:42:15 +0000 UTC]

april fools is nowadays just a fun little day for laughs. there are of course a lot of people who take it too far, thus only amusing themselves. it's those people who make holidays looked down upon. then there's the goofy stuff, like google's scent prank or devantheart. (it should be common sense that an art site with people of all ages like this one wouldn't be the best dating site.)

pranks are supposed to be good and fun, but it's all perspective. part of me would find it far fetched that a people would deny a goofy holiday because of religion, but in all seriousness it's their right, and don't have to follow another culture's game. practically everything in the world is optional, so it would be wrong to force anyone to follow or not follow something. besides, it adds that much more color to traditional diversity. all we have to do is accept.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

rui-thinik In reply to rui-thinik [2013-04-02 18:50:06 +0000 UTC]

and now that i read my comment again, it sounds kinda forceful. wish we could edit these.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Grrtomboyrd [2013-04-02 18:11:30 +0000 UTC]

You don't necessarily have to lie to mess with someone. You could say nothing and just set up tricks. Like the old put something on top of the door and when someone opens it, it falls scaring the person. Or you could hide something and put it somewhere else. I personally think the pranks that involve lying are weak and stupid.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Kinggigasmon [2013-04-02 17:57:11 +0000 UTC]

I am as always impressed by your scholarly knowledge of history and culture, especially on such an obscure subject. However, I think on this topic you're taking things much too seriously. April Fool's Day is not a time to play malicious, harmful or wicked acts of deceit on people. It is a silly holiday intended for a mutual laugh for the prankster, and upon completion, the prankee. There is a clear difference in using deception to benefit materially from the misleading of others and at their expense from playing a short-term joke that results in mutual amusement from from both parties. Sometimes, it is fun to be tricked and to realize the trick has happened.

April Fool's Day is a silly holiday designed to get a laugh for all those involved.

"Therefore, true Muslims don't participate in anything related to April Fools Day." Pardon me, but I think you're taking this subject a LITTLE too seriously. And people who take this holiday so seriously are in fact the biggest April Fool of them all.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Nayzak In reply to Kinggigasmon [2013-04-02 18:42:43 +0000 UTC]

However, I think on this topic you're taking things much too seriously.
I take everything seriously.

April Fool's Day is not a time to play malicious, harmful or wicked acts of deceit on people.
Yet malicious and harmful and wicked pranks are done for fun. when you make a prank, you can't be sure it's going to go according to your calculations. therefore, you can't say firmly that it's unharmful until it's done and finished and nobody got harmed.

There is a clear difference in using deception to benefit materially from the misleading of others and at their expense from playing a short-term joke that results in mutual amusement from from both parties. Sometimes, it is fun to be tricked and to realize the trick has happened.
First, I never said in my article anything about the prankster benefiting materially. I don't know where you got that one.
and since you're talking about mutual amusement and fun, let's see the fun in these following April Fools stories (source: internet):

a- In one tragic April Fools' case, an employer reportedly thought it would be funny to shoot a worker with a high-powered hose, resulting in serious bodily injury to the worker. A separate April Fools' incident was investigated as second-degree assault after someone spread superglue on a toilet at Wal-Mart, resulting in injuries to an unsuspecting patron.

b- Randy Wood pranked his ex-wife in 2004 by asking her to come over so he could show her something.
When she arrived at his house, Woods appeared to be hanging from a tree in his front yard (he was actually being held by a safety harness).
His unknowing ex-wife dialed 911 before he could reveal the gag. Wood was fined $1,000 and jailed for a year.

c- Two teenagers decided it would be funny to cover a stop sign in plastic wrap. They even bragged about it on their Facebook page.
Then at 4 in the afternoon on a road in Circleville, Ohio, an 80-year-old woman named Jeanne Shea drove through the intersection without stopping. Another car smashed into her. The passenger, her 85-year-old sister Mary Spangler, was killed, and Ms. Shea may have to have her leg amputated.
The young men, Derek W. Greenlee, 18, and Seth R. Stonerock, 19, were found after people read their Facebook posts and reported them to the police. They were charged with manslaughter.
* just google "April fools prank gone wrong" and you'll get more
Now these people just wanted to have 'innocent' fun by tricking others. You may think it's fine. it may be fine for you as long as you aren't involved in a stupid prank that goes wrong. while you may just laugh and have fun, others may be upset or suffer or even lose life. If this is the way you entertain yourself, we Muslims say "we are sorry, we don't joke like this". We Muslims do joke, but we prefer harmless jokes that don't involve lies, dirty tricks and playing with other people's emotions.

April Fool's Day is a silly holiday designed to get a laugh for all those involved.
Muslims don't participate in silly holidays.

Pardon me, but I think you're taking this subject a LITTLE too seriously. And people who take this holiday so seriously are in fact the biggest April Fool of them all.
Well, you are entitled to your opinion.
If you want to think I'm an April fool, think what you want. In the end, I'm who I am, not who people think I am.
I don't ask people to agree with the above article. My aim is merely to inform people of what Islam teaches and what Muslims believe. this may help people in dealing with each other.

peace

👍: 0 ⏩: 1


| Next =>