HOME | DD

Description
Season 1 MLP Rating
Season 2 MLP Rating
Season 3 MLP Rating
Season 4 MLP Rating
Season 5 MLP Rating
Season 6 MLP Rating
Season 7 MLP Rating
Season 8 MLP Rating
Season 9 MLP Rating
MLP Equestria Girls Rating

1. Princess Twilight Sparkle Part 1 - Masterpiece

This one was great. I loved the Plunderseeds, and all Discord's scenes. I loved how they summoned him while he was taking a shower and singing Winter Wrap Up, and how he was so overdramatic and knitted an arrow out of Plunderseed vines. Zecora's potion was awesome, and I got so scared when I thought Princess Luna was turning evil again, since I love Princess Luna.

2. Princess Twilight Sparkle Part 2 - Masterpiece

This was great. I can't say how relieved I was that the potion was just a flashback from the past and Luna wasn't turning evil. The journey into the forest was great and I loved how Discord says "I'm going to need more popocorn!" Priceless. The Tree of Harmony was great too, it was so beautiful when they put the Elements back in and it glowed like that. I also loved how Discord persuaded Twilight to go back and join her friends after they tried to protect her, and how he threw that party for their success, then found out the Elements were gone and Fluttershy said he'd better stop thinking about going evil again. And his maid outfit was priceless.

3. Castle Mane-ia - Average

This one was OK. It was interesting getting to see all the parts of the Castle of the Two Sisters, and learning about how Nightmare Moon's magic manifested into the Pony of Shadows. I also liked seeing Twilight go crazy over all the books. Applejack's spooky voice was awesome, too, and I loved the bit at the end when Pinkie Pie said "I let my imagination run away from me all the time. Then it comes back. With cake!"

4. Daring Don't - Excellent

Daring Don't was absolutely epic. Discovering that A.K. Yearling really was Daring Do was an amazing twist, and it was awesome to see the real Caballeron and Ahuizotl and his cats. It was great how Daring Do and Rainbow Dash worked together and that Daring learned it was important to put her trust in another pony. Awesome episode.

5. Flight to the Finish - Good

This one was good. I liked the CMCs' flag routine and the song Hearts As Strong As Horses was one of my favourite songs in the series. Although I didn't like Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon, and I still don't get why Scootaloo even listened to them. It's always been a mystery to me, when the bad guys try and get under the good guys skin, why do they listen to them!? They're obviously lying, and besides, they wouldn't be trying to get under your skin unless they were terrified you were going to beat them. Why does Scootaloo even listen? But still a good episode.

6. Power Ponies - Excellent

I absolutely loved this episode. Magic comic books that suck you into comic worlds? Epic deranged hair-raising supervillain (pun intended) with a mad evil laugh? Awesome character personas and superpowers? Absolutely terrific episode. I loved seeing all the Mane 6 use their powers, and it was cute how Spike thought he was useless, but the Mane 6 said to the Mane-iac

7. Bats! - Excellent

This one was exciting and spooky. Fluttershy turning into a Flutterbat was an awesome idea, and she was so creepy when she was in her Flutterbat form. The lesson about how you have to say no to your best friends sometimes was an excellent one, probably one of the best in Season 4. And I loved the song Bats! Applejack just has the best spooky voice.

8. Rarity Takes Manehattan - Excellent

I liked this one a lot. The song Generosity was amazing, and I loved Rarity's first fashion line, the shiny purple one. I was so mad at Suri Polomare, and it bugged me that Rarity never ratted her out. Suri was a pretty great character, though, with her voice and "mmkay"s, and Coco Pommel was just one of the sweetest characters ever! Her appearance and voice are just so cute, and her shyness only adds to her cuteness! She was absolutely adorable, especially when her eyes light up at the thought of being a costume-maker.

9. Pinkie Apple Pie - Bad

Pinkie Apple Pie was a rather forgettable episode for me. It was pretty pointless, since it didn't result in anything. Though I liked the song Apples To the Core.

10. Rainbow Falls - Excellent

This was an episode I didn't like much at first, but grew to like when I watched it more. I loved how Rainbow Dash alternated between teams, and Bulk Biceps was hilarious with his YEAH!s. Pinkie Pie's cheerleading was hilarious too, what with "P is for...uh....pain?" My favourite part was the bit near the end when Rainbow Dash confessed she was never hurt and had found it hard to choose, and Fluttershy told her to choose Cloudsdale because she loves to win, because that is the kind of true friend Fluttershy is, but Rainbow chose Ponyville instead.

11. Three's A Crowd - Excellent

Three's A Crowd was amazing, and Glass of Water is definitely my favourite montage. It's just so Discord, and I loved how utterly random the lyrics and outfits were. I loved how dramatic Discord was with the Mane 6, and his annoyed pout when he thought Twilight wasn't his friend. I also liked how he danced the FlimFlam Brothers dance with an identical boater. And I love the bit with Fluttershy at the end how he said just her presence made him feel better, and the one-liner ending where he asked for a glass of water.

12. Pinkie Pride - Excellent

One of the most entertaining episodes in Season 4. Cheese Sandwich was an absolutely terrific character, I adored everything about his wacky personality and voice, and how he mirrored Pinkie Pie so much. The songs were awesome, and so was the goof-off. And the party at the end was epic. The Cheesepie shipping was adorable, too. Pinkie and Cheese are the cheesiest couple.

13. Simple Ways - Terrible

Simple Ways was cringy and sickening, and Trenderhoof was just one of the worst characters ever. The way he latched onto Applejack and wouldn't leave her alone, constantly flirting her up when she was SO CLEARLY not interested in him just made me throw up. He just wouldn't seem to take no for an answer. That part when he says that poem and cups Applejack's chin just made me go "Oh, GAGGG!", and it makes me furious to see someone flirting up Applejack who isn't Flim. Apple Jewel was very pretty, but that was the only thing I liked about this episode.

14. Filli Vanilli - Good

This was a good episode. I absolutely adored Music In The Treetops and Find The Music In You, and it was funny seeing Fluttershy become Flutterguy again. I also loved the part where the Ponytones are singing and Cheerilee swoons over Big Mac. I do way prefer SugarMac to CheeriMac, but I still found that bit funny, after the events of Hearts And Hooves Day.

15. Twilight Time - Bad

Twilight Time I didn't like at all. It barely had any substance to it besides the CMCs getting ponies to do what they wanted because they knew a princess. Not an utterly detestable episode, but very pointless, and not one I'd want to watch again.

16. It Ain't Easy Being Breezies - Good

This one was good. I loved the Breezies and the view of their home at the end. That was really beautiful. The episode was a little repetitive, but I didn't mind, as it wasn't bad. Seabreeze was a great character, and I liked how he learned to be more kind. I especially liked how Fluttershy realized that niceness and kindness are not the same thing, and to do the right thing she had to force the Breezies to leave Ponyville.

17. Somepony to Watch Over Me - Abomination

Somepony To Watch Over Me was an absolute abomination, and I was disgusted at what the makers did to Applejack. She was SO out of character it was awful. Applejack is the most mature and together pony in the Mane 6, she would never act like such a mollycoddling idiot, being so ridiculously overprotective of Apple Bloom. She treated Apple Bloom like a baby, what with pillows on rakes and baby cot sides to her bed. Sure, she's always been protective of Apple Bloom, and that's good, because that's what big sisters are for, but this was just ridiculous, as Applejack is far too smart and mature to be so ridiculously overprotective.

18. Maud Pie - Excellent

Maud Pie actually confused me a lot when I first watched it. At first I saw Maud as a boring pony who didn't care about feelings or care to do anything fun, and I kept wishing she would liven up a bit, but then I later realized that she is just different and doesn't show emotions, and that's OK. I loved seeing her bluntness and literal interpretations, and Boulder was priceless. And it was awesome how Maud shredded apart the giant rock, and smiled at the end.

19. For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils - Good

This episode was kind of sweet. The dream scene with Sweetie Belle and Princess Luna was very cute, and I liked the part when Sweetie Belle apologized to Rarity. I get why Sweetie Belle was upset, because she worked so hard on the play and nopony cared about any of it besides the dresses, although she shouldn't have taken it out on Rarity like that. My favourite part would be when Sweetie Belle is ranting and imitates Rarity "Sweetie Belle! Fetch me some red ribbon! No, that's not red, that's cherry! No, that's not red, that's cinammon! For Pete's sake, it's all red!"

20. Leap of Faith - Masterpiece

This one was fantastic, and a big surprise, as I certainly wasn't expecting Flim and Flam to return, but I was proven wrong. The FlimFlam Miracle Curative Tonic is my second favourite song in the series, and I love how ponies knees always bounce when the twins are around. When I first saw their contraption on stage, I thought it resembled the Squeezy a little, and wondered if it had anything to do with Flim and Flam, and I doubted it at first, but when I saw their silhouettes, I knew "Yep. It's them." I especially loved the part when Applejack confronted them in their tent and they acted so playful, talking fast and back and forth, which is exactly what I love about them. I also liked the Flimjack shipping, especially when Flim puts his arm round her.

21. Testing, Testing, 1, 2, 3 - Bad

This one was bad. There was nothing in it that was worth watching at all, and even Pinkie Pie's rap wasn't that good. The lesson was rather lame, and the episode seemed to go on for ages and was very repetitive and not very interesting.

22. Trade Ya! - Average

Trade Ya! was average. It was a rather aggravating episode to watch, and there wasn't much in it that was particularly entertaining, but I did love the parts where Pinkie Pie imitates Flam to sell Twilight's books, with an identical outfit and mustache. That was priceless. It's also funny to see that Applejack and Rarity will argue over anything, and the train ride home at the end was very sweet.

23. Inspiration Manifestation - Good

This episode was spooky and exciting. Rarity getting corrupted and making everything "fabulous" was terrific. I just love her deranged voice, and how she gets so exhilarated about making everything her way, it was terrific. The green spell and the way her eyes glowed green was really creepy, too. I really liked that.

24. Equestria Games - Good

Equestria Games was good. I liked seeing the CMCs carry the flag at the ceremony and Rainbow Dash, Bulk Biceps and Fluttershy win silver. Spike singing the Cloudsdale Anthem was very mortifying and cringy to watch, but I liked how he's a hero in the Crystal Empire, with the statue. I also liked the fireworks at the end.

25. Twilight’s Kingdom Part 1 - Masterpiece

I loved this episode. The song You'll Play Your Part was one of the most heartwarming scenes yet, and all Discord's scenes were hilarious, especially where he appears in Mary Poppins getup and annoys the Mane 6 with his outfits and showmanship. And I absolutely adore how there was a whole hidden pattern throughout Season 4, with each pony facing their situations and living up to their Elements and getting their keys. That was an absolutely fantastic idea.

26. Twilight’s Kingdom Part 2 - Masterpiece

This was great. Tirek was such an awesome supervillain, and I loved Discord's sentiments, and when he apologized to Fluttershy. That was so sweet. I loved the Rainbow Light, too, and the rainbow-ified Mane 6 were awesome. Twilight's new castle was great too, and Twilight definitely deserves to be the Princess of Friendship. I especially loved the song Let the Rainbow Remind You, which is my favourite song in the series, and I loved how the rainbow was viewed by Coco Pommel, Spitfire, Cheese Sandwich, Seabreeze, Silver Shill and Discord. I also liked Discord's flirting with Celestia at the end.

Masterpiece = 4 Points
Excellent = 3 Points
Good = 2 Points
Average = 1 Point
Bad = -1 Point
Terrible = -2 Points
Abomination = -3 Points

Overall Season Score: 50

Description
Season 1 MLP Rating
Season 2 MLP Rating
Season 3 MLP Rating
Season 4 MLP Rating
Season 5 MLP Rating
Season 6 MLP Rating
Season 7 MLP Rating
Season 8 MLP Rating
Season 9 MLP Rating
MLP Equestria Girls Rating

1. Princess Twilight Sparkle Part 1 - Masterpiece

This one was great. I loved the Plunderseeds, and all Discord's scenes. I loved how they summoned him while he was taking a shower and singing Winter Wrap Up, and how he was so overdramatic and knitted an arrow out of Plunderseed vines. Zecora's potion was awesome, and I got so scared when I thought Princess Luna was turning evil again, since I love Princess Luna.

2. Princess Twilight Sparkle Part 2 - Masterpiece

This was great. I can't say how relieved I was that the potion was just a flashback from the past and Luna wasn't turning evil. The journey into the forest was great and I loved how Discord says "I'm going to need more popocorn!" Priceless. The Tree of Harmony was great too, it was so beautiful when they put the Elements back in and it glowed like that. I also loved how Discord persuaded Twilight to go back and join her friends after they tried to protect her, and how he threw that party for their success, then found out the Elements were gone and Fluttershy said he'd better stop thinking about going evil again. And his maid outfit was priceless.

3. Castle Mane-ia - Average

This one was OK. It was interesting getting to see all the parts of the Castle of the Two Sisters, and learning about how Nightmare Moon's magic manifested into the Pony of Shadows. I also liked seeing Twilight go crazy over all the books. Applejack's spooky voice was awesome, too, and I loved the bit at the end when Pinkie Pie said "I let my imagination run away from me all the time. Then it comes back. With cake!"

4. Daring Don't - Excellent

Daring Don't was absolutely epic. Discovering that A.K. Yearling really was Daring Do was an amazing twist, and it was awesome to see the real Caballeron and Ahuizotl and his cats. It was great how Daring Do and Rainbow Dash worked together and that Daring learned it was important to put her trust in another pony. Awesome episode.

5. Flight to the Finish - Good

This one was good. I liked the CMCs' flag routine and the song Hearts As Strong As Horses was one of my favourite songs in the series. Although I didn't like Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon, and I still don't get why Scootaloo even listened to them. It's always been a mystery to me, when the bad guys try and get under the good guys skin, why do they listen to them!? They're obviously lying, and besides, they wouldn't be trying to get under your skin unless they were terrified you were going to beat them. Why does Scootaloo even listen? But still a good episode.

6. Power Ponies - Excellent

I absolutely loved this episode. Magic comic books that suck you into comic worlds? Epic deranged hair-raising supervillain (pun intended) with a mad evil laugh? Awesome character personas and superpowers? Absolutely terrific episode. I loved seeing all the Mane 6 use their powers, and it was cute how Spike thought he was useless, but the Mane 6 said to the Mane-iac

7. Bats! - Excellent

This one was exciting and spooky. Fluttershy turning into a Flutterbat was an awesome idea, and she was so creepy when she was in her Flutterbat form. The lesson about how you have to say no to your best friends sometimes was an excellent one, probably one of the best in Season 4. And I loved the song Bats! Applejack just has the best spooky voice.

8. Rarity Takes Manehattan - Excellent

I liked this one a lot. The song Generosity was amazing, and I loved Rarity's first fashion line, the shiny purple one. I was so mad at Suri Polomare, and it bugged me that Rarity never ratted her out. Suri was a pretty great character, though, with her voice and "mmkay"s, and Coco Pommel was just one of the sweetest characters ever! Her appearance and voice are just so cute, and her shyness only adds to her cuteness! She was absolutely adorable, especially when her eyes light up at the thought of being a costume-maker.

9. Pinkie Apple Pie - Bad

Pinkie Apple Pie was a rather forgettable episode for me. It was pretty pointless, since it didn't result in anything. Though I liked the song Apples To the Core.

10. Rainbow Falls - Excellent

This was an episode I didn't like much at first, but grew to like when I watched it more. I loved how Rainbow Dash alternated between teams, and Bulk Biceps was hilarious with his YEAH!s. Pinkie Pie's cheerleading was hilarious too, what with "P is for...uh....pain?" My favourite part was the bit near the end when Rainbow Dash confessed she was never hurt and had found it hard to choose, and Fluttershy told her to choose Cloudsdale because she loves to win, because that is the kind of true friend Fluttershy is, but Rainbow chose Ponyville instead.

11. Three's A Crowd - Excellent

Three's A Crowd was amazing, and Glass of Water is definitely my favourite montage. It's just so Discord, and I loved how utterly random the lyrics and outfits were. I loved how dramatic Discord was with the Mane 6, and his annoyed pout when he thought Twilight wasn't his friend. I also liked how he danced the FlimFlam Brothers dance with an identical boater. And I love the bit with Fluttershy at the end how he said just her presence made him feel better, and the one-liner ending where he asked for a glass of water.

12. Pinkie Pride - Excellent

One of the most entertaining episodes in Season 4. Cheese Sandwich was an absolutely terrific character, I adored everything about his wacky personality and voice, and how he mirrored Pinkie Pie so much. The songs were awesome, and so was the goof-off. And the party at the end was epic. The Cheesepie shipping was adorable, too. Pinkie and Cheese are the cheesiest couple.

13. Simple Ways - Terrible

Simple Ways was cringy and sickening, and Trenderhoof was just one of the worst characters ever. The way he latched onto Applejack and wouldn't leave her alone, constantly flirting her up when she was SO CLEARLY not interested in him just made me throw up. He just wouldn't seem to take no for an answer. That part when he says that poem and cups Applejack's chin just made me go "Oh, GAGGG!", and it makes me furious to see someone flirting up Applejack who isn't Flim. Apple Jewel was very pretty, but that was the only thing I liked about this episode.

14. Filli Vanilli - Good

This was a good episode. I absolutely adored Music In The Treetops and Find The Music In You, and it was funny seeing Fluttershy become Flutterguy again. I also loved the part where the Ponytones are singing and Cheerilee swoons over Big Mac. I do way prefer SugarMac to CheeriMac, but I still found that bit funny, after the events of Hearts And Hooves Day.

15. Twilight Time - Bad

Twilight Time I didn't like at all. It barely had any substance to it besides the CMCs getting ponies to do what they wanted because they knew a princess. Not an utterly detestable episode, but very pointless, and not one I'd want to watch again.

16. It Ain't Easy Being Breezies - Good

This one was good. I loved the Breezies and the view of their home at the end. That was really beautiful. The episode was a little repetitive, but I didn't mind, as it wasn't bad. Seabreeze was a great character, and I liked how he learned to be more kind. I especially liked how Fluttershy realized that niceness and kindness are not the same thing, and to do the right thing she had to force the Breezies to leave Ponyville.

17. Somepony to Watch Over Me - Abomination

Somepony To Watch Over Me was an absolute abomination, and I was disgusted at what the makers did to Applejack. She was SO out of character it was awful. Applejack is the most mature and together pony in the Mane 6, she would never act like such a mollycoddling idiot, being so ridiculously overprotective of Apple Bloom. She treated Apple Bloom like a baby, what with pillows on rakes and baby cot sides to her bed. Sure, she's always been protective of Apple Bloom, and that's good, because that's what big sisters are for, but this was just ridiculous, as Applejack is far too smart and mature to be so ridiculously overprotective.

18. Maud Pie - Excellent

Maud Pie actually confused me a lot when I first watched it. At first I saw Maud as a boring pony who didn't care about feelings or care to do anything fun, and I kept wishing she would liven up a bit, but then I later realized that she is just different and doesn't show emotions, and that's OK. I loved seeing her bluntness and literal interpretations, and Boulder was priceless. And it was awesome how Maud shredded apart the giant rock, and smiled at the end.

19. For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils - Good

This episode was kind of sweet. The dream scene with Sweetie Belle and Princess Luna was very cute, and I liked the part when Sweetie Belle apologized to Rarity. I get why Sweetie Belle was upset, because she worked so hard on the play and nopony cared about any of it besides the dresses, although she shouldn't have taken it out on Rarity like that. My favourite part would be when Sweetie Belle is ranting and imitates Rarity "Sweetie Belle! Fetch me some red ribbon! No, that's not red, that's cherry! No, that's not red, that's cinammon! For Pete's sake, it's all red!"

20. Leap of Faith - Masterpiece

This one was fantastic, and a big surprise, as I certainly wasn't expecting Flim and Flam to return, but I was proven wrong. The FlimFlam Miracle Curative Tonic is my second favourite song in the series, and I love how ponies knees always bounce when the twins are around. When I first saw their contraption on stage, I thought it resembled the Squeezy a little, and wondered if it had anything to do with Flim and Flam, and I doubted it at first, but when I saw their silhouettes, I knew "Yep. It's them." I especially loved the part when Applejack confronted them in their tent and they acted so playful, talking fast and back and forth, which is exactly what I love about them. I also liked the Flimjack shipping, especially when Flim puts his arm round her.

21. Testing, Testing, 1, 2, 3 - Bad

This one was bad. There was nothing in it that was worth watching at all, and even Pinkie Pie's rap wasn't that good. The lesson was rather lame, and the episode seemed to go on for ages and was very repetitive and not very interesting.

22. Trade Ya! - Average

Trade Ya! was average. It was a rather aggravating episode to watch, and there wasn't much in it that was particularly entertaining, but I did love the parts where Pinkie Pie imitates Flam to sell Twilight's books, with an identical outfit and mustache. That was priceless. It's also funny to see that Applejack and Rarity will argue over anything, and the train ride home at the end was very sweet.

23. Inspiration Manifestation - Good

This episode was spooky and exciting. Rarity getting corrupted and making everything "fabulous" was terrific. I just love her deranged voice, and how she gets so exhilarated about making everything her way, it was terrific. The green spell and the way her eyes glowed green was really creepy, too. I really liked that.

24. Equestria Games - Good

Equestria Games was good. I liked seeing the CMCs carry the flag at the ceremony and Rainbow Dash, Bulk Biceps and Fluttershy win silver. Spike singing the Cloudsdale Anthem was very mortifying and cringy to watch, but I liked how he's a hero in the Crystal Empire, with the statue. I also liked the fireworks at the end.

25. Twilight’s Kingdom Part 1 - Masterpiece

I loved this episode. The song You'll Play Your Part was one of the most heartwarming scenes yet, and all Discord's scenes were hilarious, especially where he appears in Mary Poppins getup and annoys the Mane 6 with his outfits and showmanship. And I absolutely adore how there was a whole hidden pattern throughout Season 4, with each pony facing their situations and living up to their Elements and getting their keys. That was an absolutely fantastic idea.

26. Twilight’s Kingdom Part 2 - Masterpiece

This was great. Tirek was such an awesome supervillain, and I loved Discord's sentiments, and when he apologized to Fluttershy. That was so sweet. I loved the Rainbow Light, too, and the rainbow-ified Mane 6 were awesome. Twilight's new castle was great too, and Twilight definitely deserves to be the Princess of Friendship. I especially loved the song Let the Rainbow Remind You, which is my favourite song in the series, and I loved how the rainbow was viewed by Coco Pommel, Spitfire, Cheese Sandwich, Seabreeze, Silver Shill and Discord. I also liked Discord's flirting with Celestia at the end.

Masterpiece = 4 Points
Excellent = 3 Points
Good = 2 Points
Average = 1 Point
Bad = -1 Point
Terrible = -2 Points
Abomination = -3 Points

Overall Season Score: 50