Comments: 13
ResidentialPsycho In reply to Vivacia18 [2014-02-26 04:50:17 +0000 UTC]
Hahaha. Tower of God is really good, too.
Sometimes, it's really hard to find good stories. Most of the things I read are mediocre. I just struggle for that gem of goodness.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ResidentialPsycho In reply to Vivacia18 [2014-02-27 18:01:05 +0000 UTC]
I think webtoons really are more free. They are created freely from the start with no magazine or editorial limitations. They can do whatever they please. Depending on who publishes them, they can work out payment depending on how popular their series are. Not to mention how easily accessible they are. With traditional graphic novels, the creators have to do what their publishers tell them. It limits their freedom quite a bit. They can't end series when they want to and they have to be careful with the ratings and focus on staying in a certain genre and all that nonsense. They can also go on lengthy breaks without too much concern and have more options available to them. Since the editors and publishers influence them so much, a lot of Japanese manga really feels the same. In American comics, sometimes they even change the artist and writer for the series, so it ends up inconsistent and with different quality... They did that to Catwoman and really ticked me off. It was a good series until they changed it. It felt like some bad knock-off.
I just want SATISFACTION. I hate the ones that aren't so bad that you quit them but don't get good enough for you to say that you really like that series. It's so painful when they're something really good that gets cancelled because it doesn't get high enough ratings or whatever. That drives me crazy. It was really funny when they did that with Shonen Jump's Cross Manage... It was really popular in the US magazine and the cancellation about caused a riot. During an interview, the US editors mentioned that series specifically. Webtoons can freely appeal to anyone and only get cancelled by their creators (I think), so they end when they want. They get direct feedback from the readers, which influences them, but stories that do what the writer wants regardless are the most interesting.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Vivacia18 In reply to ResidentialPsycho [2014-02-28 06:12:03 +0000 UTC]
Gah, changing artists/writers is a terrible idea no matter the media, it never ends well. The only time that's acceptable is when someone is seriously ill or dead:I And even then, I think many would be happier with a brief summary of the story that's left to tell rather than an attempt at imitation; or at least that's been my experience.
Yes, same here! At least when you outright dislike a story you can just write it off and move on, but the mediocre ones just eat away at you, because you know they could have been so much more, and they just... weren't.
Hmm, sounds like it's a good thing I hadn't heard about Cross Manage until now - I've had enough cancellation heartbreak. Though that general situation is the real kicker in liking foreign work - we're stuck with the ramifications of a series' popularity in another country, with no regard to how it's received overseas. Not that I don't understand why of course, but it still hurts:/
Ahaha, yes I loved it when I read in one of currygom's Q&A that reader opinions would not influence the story at all It bugs me when readers hassle a writer to do this and that with characters they don't have a full understanding of, especially when it's just to fulfill their own fantasies. You started reading because you like this authors work, yes? So try trusting them (and your own taste in following them!) a little, hmm?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ResidentialPsycho In reply to Vivacia18 [2014-03-01 02:53:16 +0000 UTC]
I agree. With only a summary, we can let our imaginations fill it in. We get our questions answered, and we don't have to feel annoyed because of any poor imitations. Imitations just don't feel right or they don't understand characters well or they get little details wrong or the narration style is different.... It's very uncomfortable.
Despite being a sports manga, Cross Manage was actually interesting. It had good characters and beautiful artwork.
Hahaha. Currygom is funny. Just "no." SIU of ToG said something similar.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
ResidentialPsycho In reply to Vivacia18 [2014-02-15 00:02:52 +0000 UTC]
It's an excellent series. The character development is really top-notch, and all of the characters exist in their own right. The story is layered on many levels, and the natural comedy will jump out at you from time to time. The setting is also very interesting and detailed. The world they live in is so cool. *o*
I'm glad to have lured another one over! It takes awhile to really get into it, so read patiently at the beginning.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Vivacia18 In reply to ResidentialPsycho [2014-02-15 01:33:18 +0000 UTC]
Don't worry, I rarely reject anything completely - not immediately liking a story is usually more a sign that I'm not in the mood for it than that I don't like it, so I always come back eventually^^ And I generally really like webtoons, so I'm not too worries about this one - I liked the last one I read so much (Orange Marmalade) that I got a Naver account so I could rate the webtoon, since according to wiki the authors pay is determined by the webtoon rating^^
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ResidentialPsycho In reply to Vivacia18 [2014-02-15 02:57:02 +0000 UTC]
Oooh. That's some dedication. Orange Marmalade took vampires and turned it into an interesting discrimination topic. I really liked how they put together a band. It was pretty cool.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ResidentialPsycho In reply to Vivacia18 [2014-02-19 01:25:32 +0000 UTC]
I listened to a couple. On YouTube, the top comments for them often included "I was brought here by Orange Marmalade!"
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Vivacia18 In reply to ResidentialPsycho [2014-02-19 01:31:08 +0000 UTC]
Lol, I often feel sorry for youtube authors for repeat comments. It's a hazard anywhere on the internet, but it seems worse on youtube (then again it could just be me).
👍: 0 ⏩: 0