HOME | DD
SushiGoat — Anti-Critique - STAMP
Published: 2012-12-13 16:15:56 +0000 UTC; Views: 3808; Favourites: 78; Downloads: 8
Redirect to original
Description
2022 edit: Lol, guys... I made this stamp when I was 15.Listen, the moral of the story is let people be. Sometimes people wanna do things casually. Imagine some kids playing soccer at the park and you, a stranger, approach them and start giving them unsolicited advice on their form. It's weird right? It's the same thing here. People that want to improve their craft will seek out how to do so. That's where I stand really. It's been 10 years and people still chatting it up here. I love it ya'll. Have a great day and keep drawing!
--
It is my personal preference to refuse critique.
Now before you assume things or make judgements please hear me out:
-----------------------------------------------
I am not against critique in all forms. If you enjoy having others point out flaws in your artwork so that you may improve, that is wonderful. Everyone is allowed to have opinions.
What I am against however is the brutal attacks and discrimination against people like me who do not enjoy learning in this way. For example:
:thumb74568299: :thumb177625250: (I disagree with the thought that being able to handle negativity, labeled critique or not, coincides with maturity, however some things this stamp description says I do agree with. The first however, is straight up rude and inconsiderate.)
I have always been self taught and art has always been a very special thing to me. It is my favorite hobby and I'm simply not interested in strict improvement. I do it to enjoy myself.
A lot of people have the misconception that if someone refuses/doesn't like critique that they are either vain, or just 'butthurt'.
Perhaps in some cases this is true, but in mine, and i'm sure other people's cases...
We just don't learn that way.
I personally do not learn from others pointing out flaws in my work. It discourages me and makes me unhappy. Often times people say "Suck it up. It's the only way to improve." and other things like that. I do not think that is true. It is not based on fact and there is no proof that critique is the only way to learn. That should be obvious.
Believe it or not, some people don't like hearing negative things, respectively or not, about something that came from their soul and that they worked hard on. If people can't help but feel that way, they shouldn't have to go through it. Everyone is different. Not everyone can think like you.
I learn through spotting my own mistakes and using references and watching others. Critique is just something that upsets me and makes me ashamed to be a part of the art community.
As I said before, it is not wrong to like critique. And critique itself is not bad. What is bad is the people that believe "You're not a real artist if you don't accept critique." and similar things like that.
For example, I drew a picture once and someone rudely commented "Needs work"
Now I understand that person specifically was a troll and their comment was in no way proper critique form, but allow me to state my point.
Even though the picture was flawed, as is everything by nature of the art world since "Perfection doesn't exist",
even if I had the power to fix the anatomy flaws or the color clashes or whatever... I wouldn't.
Because I like the picture the way it is. I like the perks it has. The way it stands. Simply everything about it. To me...
The flaws make the picture perfect.
Is that not what art is? If perfection doesn't exist... What is the point of trying to get there?
I'm not saying improvement is bad or that you should shun critique... It's just that, for the people that only wish to create art for their own personal pleasure, and who can't handle critique for whatever reason they may have, leave them out of the strict critiquing part of the art community where some people think it actually has 'rules'.
Just let people be themselves.
Respect their decisions and do not push your opinions onto them. Whatever argument you think justifies you hurting another persons feelings because
"You're not a real artist." or "You're a little bitch if you don't accept critique." I can tell you right now is wrong and you should really rethink your judgement.
Perhaps some people are butthurt and are too weak to handle critique. They shouldn't HAVE to be strong enough to take it if they don't want to. It's not your GLORIOUS BURDEN to help other people improve their artwork.
If they ask for it, fine. If they are against it for themselves, respect that and back off.
I hope maybe some of you will realize my point and maybe agree with me? That would be nice. But if you don't agree and think every artist is obligated to accept your criticisms, well, just know that there was no contract stating they had to when they 'signed up' to become an artist.
---------------------------------------------------
I really don't mean to fight with anyone. I just wanted to get my point across and explain my standing on critique. I hope some people can agree with me at least.
- - -
Allies:
:thumb86419918: :thumb78173001: :thumb149948357:
:thumb295144875:
- - -
Related content
Comments: 85
👍: 2 ⏩: 1
👍: 1 ⏩: 1
👍: 1 ⏩: 1
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
I rlly agree with this . Some people (including my friends) on Instagram , call me rude , b*tchy and started to get mad at me for not accepting criticism and tips . But one of my bestie said that I didnt want to improve my art but thats is not the reason , its just people dont want to be criticized .
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I went to an Art highschool and critique culture is bullshit tbh
Every piece we made it was a requirement that people find SOMETHING wrong with it, and everyone in the class had to point something out so we could 'improve'.
The comments on this super old stamp are a riot. People really care about the wrong things man. Let people make imperfect art.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Honestly; If someone likes their own work; why should they care what other people think; and why should they listen to any nay-saying criticism they have to offer, when the creator of said work, likes it just the way it is?!
👍: 2 ⏩: 0
Although i like constructive criticism and it's a good way to improve if you want to improve on your own that's understandable
👍: 2 ⏩: 0
i know many people here miss the point about.
the criticism is not obligatory, because already exist people which abuse of that excuse for harrass someone for disliking something, i stopped to enable the critique widget because a lot of people were using for harrass me and for avoid any further drama i had to remove them from any submissions
👍: 2 ⏩: 0
Just don´t pust your art on a public site!
'I don´t need critiques, I see every mistake by myself.' - You can see some of them, that´s right, but it´s always better to let others take a look too. And even if you see and know about all your mistakes - why do you continue doing them? You won´t ever make it in the creative industry, my friend. And if you´re doing art as your hobby, do you think it´s better to stagnate than to improve yourself? I can´t understand this childish and immature attitude.
Putting a stamp like this at your profile and don´t disable comments looks like forcing others to praise your work. The internet is not your safe spot and there´s freedom of speech, luckily.
👍: 0 ⏩: 2
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
"Just don´t pust your art on a public site!"
is not a justification for doing what you want. there is morality you know?
👍: 2 ⏩: 0
I'm not like ANTI-Critique, I just prefer to try to improve on my own, that and I am perfectly happy with my work as is. The only people I really trust to give me critism are my close friends.
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
If you're publicly posting your work online you can't escape the possibility of criticism, that's just not the way things work. And saying you don't want critique basically means you don't want any chance to improve your work at all, which is extremely closed minded.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
"And saying you don't want critique basically means you don't want any chance to improve your work at all, which is extremely closed minded."
lol
👍: 1 ⏩: 1
Why should an artist improve their work, when they like it just the way they made it?!!
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
To quote from Patrick:
"Tell me you honest opinion- on how great it was!"
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
The only time I don't like negative critique is when people are criticizing a stylistic choice that doesn't accurately reflect on my full ability. Like if I draw something with unnatural anatomy intentionally and someone feels the need to tell me I need to learn how to draw anatomy properly. It's not that I don't understand realistic anatomy, it's that I chose to make it unrealistic for a certain piece. Heck, those people could easily just look at the rest of my gallery and clearly see that. Then I get called butthurt for not accepting that kind of critique when they're basically acting like I'm an amateur who should feel blessed to have their opinion. Get out of here with that.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Seriously, this is somehow true. But it can´t work for Deviantart for 2 reasons.
The first: You can just not accept comments at all. Some artists just dont allow comments.
If that is no option, then its like you saying. "Please only tell me nice things about it." And i dont need to tell you how that sounds.
The Second: This is the Internet. Accepting comments, mean any comments. You can´t stop trolls by any means. They are trolls after all.
And most other people who read this here, will just avoid a comment at all.
If i see you are not accepting that i can say what i do not like, then i wont tell what i like.
I say my opinion or not, but i wont cut half of it away. Thats useless and not my opinion anymore. I would feel like a news reporter in a police state.
Also, if someone does a unfair critique people will tell this to the person. (If enough people see that.)
That said, in my opinion, you are free to do what you want. If you want no no critique, then this is totally fine with me.
But i can´t stop the trolls, no one can. And you miss out the postive aspects of my comment and those that are acting like me.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
This is an art website!!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I agree with you on this point. And?
I am nto sure what you want me to say with this? Could you please be a bit more specific why you said this and what you even want to say with that?
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
If you don't what criticism then why are you on the internet. Usually on the internet if you say to not do something people do it anyway, so I'm saying is that its just better to ignore it rather then telling them not to do it. Btw I like your art especially the super jail fan art.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
No it's not "br0". This is an art sharing website, yes you cannot escape criticism here or any other websites in the internet. However there two choices you can do when you get one, either you "suck it up and accept it." or humbly disagree and ignore it. I can obviously tell you did NOT bother reading the description.
I am sorry for the mean comment but please read before typing.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Don't want critique? Then don't post it and get the fuck off dA.
👍: 0 ⏩: 2
What if the person just wants to show their artwork ? You shouldn't tell other people to fuck off a site just because they don't want something, Toasty
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
If they want to show it off, so be it. But I would be wary of where to post it (not so much as a way to avoid it, but rather many communities online are territorial and batshit crazy). I wouldn't tell them to fuck off, not unless they royally fuck up somewhere. As long as their relatively harmless, things should be good.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Criticism is not meant to be shoved to someone's ass. You know we give and get criticism however saying that someone is unwelcome to Deviantart because they "cannot" accept criticism is where I draw the line. They said it themselves in the description, THEY DO NOT HAVE ANYTHING AGAINST CRITICISM. People like you annoy me. I criticize art however I do not push the artist to do what I said because I am merely pointing out their mistakes and they have the rights to accept or decline it.
👍: 2 ⏩: 0
I agree with this completely.
I'm the kind of person who believes that art is neither good or bad, just a matter of personal taste. Art IS subjective after all, so the people who get all self-righteous regarding the importance of their critiques really annoy the crap out of me. XP
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
Well... I'm going to be honest: I agree and enjoyed your description, but I can't use the stamp since I do accept some critique, but only those done in good faith, pointing good and bad things with real solutions and suggestions on how to improve. I like my critique rounded and balanced, not revolving only on negative stuff without even offering solutions and suggestions.
I also draw as a personal passion and a lifetime hobby. I'm self taught and I grew up almost without critique. The ones that really helped me came from myself (I'm very self critical) and from someone whose experience and knowledge is absolute to me.
However, to me, critique is too overrated. I mean, it's good for improvement, sure, but it's not everything and certainly is not something worth to tear your clothes and hair off. Also practice and experimenting helps you grow. Getting in touch with your art and working on it is what eventually brings out the desired results.
It saddens me that a lot of people use "critique" to harm you in any way or justify their assholic attitude. And even worse: use the "you don't accept critique" as an excuse for cyberbullying. It's a sad, sad day when someone who does not wish critique is seen as a "whiny bitch" that deserve to be shamed publicily, pointed out, hated by everyone and harassed forever". No way. If someone does not desire critique, then we have to respect his/her wish even if we don't approve or understand. Respect and be respected back. Live and let live. Also, as you correctly say, it's not their glorious burden to help them improve, so really, why caring that much? Why the fuss and big drama?
Even in those cases when the critique is respectful, useful and meaningful and the artist throws you a temper tantrum or blocks you right away, you gotta learn to lose and move on. Making drama because someone rejected your critique is EXACTLY the same as making a circus because of a single critique. Drama is not a choice in any side. Maturity and moving on is the key in both sides.
Cheers.
👍: 2 ⏩: 2
very very well said, I agree completely
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
I can't understand this type of view. If you can't accept a costructive critique what you'll do in real life when rude people will say you really BAD things?
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
I do agree with you ^.^ I like to improve at my own pace.
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
I don't mind if someone specifically states that they don't want a critique, but people like samcollends bug me a lot. They ask for a critique, and when you give them one they go apeshit crazy. If you don't want a critique don't ask for one and just say that you don't want one.
👍: 1 ⏩: 0
I agree with everything you said!
I'm way too sensitive to accept critiques, so I never ask for one. XD
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Although I agree, I think an artist should say clearly that they don't want critiques, especially if they can't take them. Otherwise people will put their two cents in.
For example, I offered a suggestion to someone's OC, and guess what? They completely flipped out, calling me rude and a "troll", even though it was just a simple, lighthearted suggestion. I was pretty mad.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I understand. Sometimes people are a /little/ too sensitive
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
| Next =>